Read on Twitter
So an interesting thing in the "D&D Orcs are racist" 
--which is correct -- is it's relation to the Satanic Panic of the 80's and through that White US Evangelical Christianity.
1/
--which is correct -- is it's relation to the Satanic Panic of the 80's and through that White US Evangelical Christianity.1/
So in 70's OD&D humanoids exist, and are badly racially coded, as in Tolkien. Yet, 70's D&D doesn't presume player morality - it has the wargamers fallacy of equal sides (which leads to far too many panzercorps fans, but...) played without moral lens.
2/
2/
Orcs in OD&D are monster, but ones that neutral and chaotic PCs can hire as mercenaries. They aren't coded as essentially evil. I know it's a small comfort if any. Plus evil humans (e.g. bandits and berserkers) play a much larger role on enemies tables.
3/
3/
Humanoids, and essentialism about them, aren't as common a foe until BADD and other largely Christian fundamentalist critics of D&D begin critiquing D&D as a game of amoral murder.
4/
4/
Even killing bad people: necromancers and bandits makes for moral outrage. Better to argue one's violence is morally good - in the blunt way of US Evangelical morals. Monsters are embodiments of cosmic evil and sin.
5/
5/
This is one of the ways 80's D&D pushed back against the Panic. It codified its conflicts as lacking moral nuance, and built settings with clear "heroic" narratives.
6/
6/
One might think this is a time to talk smack about the Hickmans, but it's not - Dragonlance is morally clear, and has esulting ethical issues, but Dragonmen at least aren't part of an imperialist tradition (I think?)
7/
7/
Better to compare the Orcs in the last of the B series of adventures with those in the early ones. B11 King's Festival comes to mind. Orcs in a hole, raiders and kidnappers without reason who attack on sight. This is the essentialist model.
8/
8/
B11 also has very heavy handed advice about forcing good morality (killing orcs and saving priests) on the players - making D&D morally safe, even instructional - maybe even for conservative Christians. The fear of backlash is almost palpable in BECMI.
9/
9/
None of this fixes orcs. They can't be fixed today. Even WOWs "good orcs" are a mess of noble savage stereotypes, and OD&Ds were steeped in Tolkien's British Imperialism.
10/
10/
Still, the moral variety and play implied in B2's orcs with thier children, rivalries, goblin enemies and seeming resentment of the Chaos Church feels far more redeemable and less essentialist.
11/
11/
So certainly calling out the vile racial essentialism in 5E and the entire "evil humanoid" concept is important, but take a moment to consider that fantasy worlds without nuance lend themselves to it more readily then those with.
12/
12/
