#Reviewer

Louise Tully

LM_Tully

Is there guidance on being a peer reviewer? When am I qualified, how do I decide whether to accept, should I base it on familiarity with topic/methods/both? The chances of

Jason Coupet

ProfessaJay

My RnR process might be quirky, but it more or less works for me. When I get the decision letter, I read it right away. I read the editor letter

Marco Taddei

taddeima

“On the transparency of the publishing process”: a thread based on a true story.I want to share a recent experience that a friend had with the editorial handling of a

Philip Armstrong

SuperCooltendo

Jesus this is the craziest story, and another example of why judgement-based criticism of games is misguided.https://twitter.com/charlesrandall/status/1264047502875078656 It’s easy to assume that any given game was made in a vacuum

Stuart Syvret

StuartSyvret

Considered in-the-round. “THE DARK ZONEHow the British Mafia Blew its CoverThe author of this document was struck by the reaction of an early reviewer from overseas who, after commenting on

Jill Filipovic

JillFilipovic

Just saw a book review on @ArcDigi co-authored by "a philosopher who prefers to remain anonymous." Seriously? What possible justification is there for publishing that anonymously? It's cowardly, unaccountable, unprofessional,

Phil Edwards

DrPhilEdwards

Reviewer *3* you say?Oh $Journal, you're spoiling me! It's just me who gets these too-amused-to-be-pissy "there's certainly *something* here but dear oh dear" reviews, isn't it? These "who is *this*

Nick Brown

sTeamTraen

This (very valid) point reminds me of a related question I have about the confidentiality of data. A short (I hope) thread. /1https://twitter.com/simoncolumbus/status/1263741877284716544 I am fairly skeptical of many of

hiugregg 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🥗

HiuGregg

Per a recent read, I'm ruminating over where social commentary in a book starts and ends....mostly where it ends.When past a certain depth, is commentary in a book a thing

🥧 SUZANNE 🥧

425suzanne

External factors in selecting BG reviewersReachContent QualityGame taste fitAudience nichePast reviewsPersonalityInternal factors in selecting BG reviewersOverall reviewer pool mixProduction statusPre-prod copy costLanded production costShi

Ben Kuhn

benskuhn

One thing we do at Wave that I really like is *post-deploy* code review.“Wat?!” Yep! Once you’re done coding, type “bors merge” and 15 minutes later your code is in

Vulp || Commissions closed

TheVulpineHero1

This will seem like a weird flex, but probably one of the weirdest ways my hobby has affected my life is that I don't really feel comfortable writing about videogames

M. S. AtKisson

iGrrrl

Slide of the day. NIH reviewer give overall impact and individual scores for each of the 5 review criteria. The Approach criterion score most corresponds with Overall Impact score.Slide is

katemessner

KateMessner

There's been a push in certain circles for "patriotic curriculum" that discourages kids from looking at American history through a critical lens. Educators should be pushing back on that. Hard.

John B. Holbein

JohnHolbein1

For the first time, I've been brought in as a new reviewer on a manuscript that received an R&R. Previously, the paper received (and responded to) 3 very thorough reviews.Do

Naomi Havron, PhD

NaomiHavron

Very excited to have @mirbabineau and my #RegisteredrReport stage2 accepted to Developmental Science! As one of the reviewers said, this is probably one of the first RRs to be accepted