after calming down i’ve managed to gather my thoughts. dark josie started out saying how josie has been repressing something right? why she won’t accept the real reason she doesn’t wanna go back to sbs. she kept dropping little hints and she kept saying josie doesn’t get it.

she also mentioned josie cannot live a happy human life, and josie ranted about how she’ll never have a happy life and why her relationships don’t work and there’s a reason for that. josie’s mind immediately went to “you’re gonna tell me i’m weak and i always ruin relationships”

dark josie said “i never said you won’t live a happy life” and josie continued with “a happy human life” she kept saying how josie doesn’t want to take back her magic but we’ve already gone through the whole “josie is afraid of turning dark again” so it must be something else no?

she said her friend was in danger and she didn’t want to take back her magic yet she was so desperate to find a solution to save hope and dark josie said “why should i care?” and then josie yelled “because i do” THAT’S what dark josie was getting at.

dark josie was getting josie to crack without actually answering her own questions. she also mentioned “you could’ve asked any of your friends and instead you come to me” which means this has been troubling josie for quite a while, and when dark josie is about to say something

landon comes in. they also paralleled hope telling josie she’s strong to josie telling hope she can fight the thing. she took back her magic to save hope, but in order to save her she had to stab her, and she couldn’t bring herself to do it ??? like hello ???

this whole thing was hinting at hope clearly being josie’s weakness yet the reason she’s not going back to sbs. like it’s right there and if you can’t see it well! just wait.