ok, back by nobody's demand: nj reacting to another group's entire discography! this time it is seventeen. in this, like in many other things, i am inspired by myri, so thank/blame them. thread commences now!

shining diamond - slip into the diamond life? is that a threat?

on a real note: god i love a pop song with trumpets. they're getting off to a really good start.

cinematic parallels between this and the shinee world,,, an essay is already in the works

adore u - ok this seriously reminds me of shinee. kind of like a more modern love like oxygen.

oh neoreul noraehae you-hoo! and i recognise another bit because it came up on amazing saturday! this is a fun and funky tune!

ah yeah - what do you mean this isn't the exid song

side note: those boys can rap!

jam jam - what do you mean this isn't the iu song

20 - this is from a youth slice of life kdrama where a group of friends in their senior year fall in love and learn to appreciate life and being young and the sun is always shining except when one of the characters is sad

lotto (vernon solo) - what do you mean this isn't the exo song

also vernon feat. don mills *chef's kiss* and i very much appreciate the toy story wordplay

it's been a while since i've listened to this kind of hiphop but OOF. he good

bucket list (bumzu feat. vernon) - oh dear this is a very good song. there's a real danger i'll like this music. oh noooo

he's seventeen... he's young as a motherfucker... WAIT HE WAS 17?!?!?!!?

honestly mad respect to idols for being able to debut so young when i was a teen i was too busy uhhh crying

fronting - pentagon? is that you?

wow i enjoy being able to tell when groups have a similar sound but yeah this kind of sound makes me nostalgic <3

mansae - bop! i wish i had something intelligent or funny to say but worms for brains atm

when i grow up - oh soft... i am on a beach with someone i like and life is good

also wow they're singers. just in case you needed reminding

omg - enough yearning for a lover, time for some Hipped Hop

"i want you to say my name" i can't recognise your voices yet i'm so sorry

rock - somehow these vibes all feel very familiar... but yeah this is false advertising because this is not a rock song. not that i'm complaining! i personally think they should release a load of songs claiming to be one genre that are actually another

q&a - seventeen & AILEE?!

also, obligatory joke: what do you mean this isn't the wonshik song

chocolate (yoon jong shin, svt) - was struck by the difference in vibe and then i saw it was an ost and i was like Ah. but yeah sounds are nice!

wait hang on joke: what do you mean this isn't the shinee song

sickness (vernon feat. pledis girlz) - oh fuck. oh FUCK. oh this is a SONG. oh NO. oh sweet lord.

i looked at the lyrics. GOD.

so um. i accidentally listened to sickness by vernon on repeat over the past day. and suffice it to say i'm still very emotional! but i'll move on for now because otherwise i'll never finish it

no f.u.n - oh this is very seventeen. seventeen i think this is very seventeen of you

aju nice - AWWWWWWWW YEAH

i've heard it so many times i've kind of absorbed the lyrics by osmosis? at least for most of the vocal bits? anyway 기분 기분 기분 oh nice!

healing - they make such good music to run on a beach to. where is my group of misfit friends i can go on a beach trip with while we stand on the cusp of a major life change which we ignore in favour of basking in our youth

there are some (very minor) jazz influences in this song and you know how i feel about jazz (very positively)

i get the vibe that the lyrics are going to put me in my feelings (from my very limited understanding of what i hear) so uh. i'll put that aside for now

simple - oh dear. woozi is very good at this 'making songs with a positive message' thing (i looked at the lyrics this time)

i am indeed a particle of dust!

i heard a little 이 밤이 지나면 in the bridge... nice 이 밤 by jin of bts reference

space - i humbly request seventeen to stop making songs that resonate with the experience of young people please or i might end up feeling emotions

chuck - the change in vibe really threw me for a loop but what the funk!! this song is very cool

pretty u - oh i really like this!!!!! vibes are very good, much appreciated

i don't have anything funny to say i just really enjoy the vibes of this song. feels like i am watching a group of friends have fun in an arcade but one of them has a crush on another one and keeps stealing glances but the other one is oblivious

still lonely - thank god i like this song i was afraid of jenna's wrath. but yeah it's cool! the vibes feel kinda more chill but this is still very noticeably Seventeen. good on them!

hit song - igeon yuhaengga... fair enough!

got to the bridge. HELLO?! dokyeom and seungkwan my beloveds...

say yes - dokyeom and seungkwan my beloveds !!!!!!!!

god i love it when people sing good

drift away - nooooo don't make songs about regret and nostalgia and youth and time you're so sexy ahaha

will be stewing in some thoughts

adore u (vocal team ver) - OH FUCK OFF.

this is a different song??????? this is just??? a different song?????? SHUT UP!!!!!

FUCK OFFFFFFFF THEIR VOCAL RUNS ARE SO GOOD!!!

i love it when people sing so well that it makes me angry

monday to saturday (hiphop team ver) - WAIT it took me so long to realise that this was mansae... anyway that's because this is a different song

see normally i don't like hearing new versions of songs i've already heard. good thing this is a different song!

it ends on such a funky chord love that

shining diamond (performance team ver.) - again i'm fairly certain i've never heard this song before!

love letter - what do you mean this isn't the vixx song

anyway this is just nice! very good sounds!

yosm (feat. woozi) - oh i think this is a good song. and woozi voice is very nice

very bold decision to romanise 요즘 as yosm i appreciate that

beautiful - what do you mean this isn't the shinee song

anyway i appreciate the vibes of this! it has kind of edm/house vibes whilst not being fully edm/house and i respect that

boom boom - what do you mean this isn't the momoland song

but i do love the vibes of this,,, i detect a hint of funk which i very much enjoy (plus it reminds me a little bit of adore you)

highlight - again, edm vibes without being Too edm... i enjoy this.

lean on me - what do you mean this isn't the wonshik song

also holy shit this is such a song???? swing rhythm??? cool chord progression??? hiphop unit you've outdone yourselves

you all know how i feel about swing/jazz/r&b/soul/any derivative genre

fast pace - oh this is such a fun little song?? feels a little dangerous...

it has a kind of latin vibe which i enjoy

don't listen in secret - oh no. ohhhh dear. ohhhhhhhh no.

woozi is so good at making songs and vocal unit are so good at singing them.

i don't know - yeah neither do i. this song is really good though omg

spring flower - losing my mind over 웃음꽃 피워요, 그대 미소에 봄이 돼줄게요... woozi you are so good at this

the idea that a SMILE is a FLOWER and that you can NOURISH the smile of your significant other by being its SPRING. grrrrrrrr

don't wanna cry - yeah i know this one!!! and it's a real good song!!! and they're right i don't wanna cry either!!!!

habit - THIS IS SUCH A SONG??????

once again, woozi is so good at writing songs and vocal unit are so good at singing them

unfortunately i keep hearing 그때처럼 (like then) as 늑대처럼 (like a wolf) which substantially affects the mood

if i - oh another song???? musicians making songs???? wow this is very good i highly endorse it

swimming fool - oh this is a funky little tune. a wild little number. i enjoy it a lot.

my i - this sounds like it could be ed sheeran's shape of you in another life. not sure how to feel about that fact.

anyway this song wins purely by virtue of the fact i haven't heard it to death

crazy in love - what do you mean this isn't the beyonce song

i really like it!!!!!! i have nothing fun to say i just think they make good sounds!!!

cinematic love (yang da il feat. dk) - ok jenna already showed me this earlier and i believe my response was "why would you show me this" and that still stands! ahhhhhhhh he sings good

intro new world - i feel like i am on the verge of something. what? i cannot say.

change up - AWWWWWWW YEAH this was one of the few svt songs i knew and yeah they're so good at making songs

if you add brass to any kpop song it makes it elite (change up, aju nice, woof woof, last romeo) i don't make the rules

woozi did not have to sing so high but he chose to do so and for this we must thank him

without you - saw that the korean title was like pushing down my hat and i must admit i was confused at first but oh. i see now.

they are very good at this music thing i think

clap - another song i know!!!! i remember hearing this like 4 years ago and being like "oh this song is super cool" and then doing nothing about it and now here i am being like "oh this song is super cool" except i now have people who actively want me to like svt

loving the guitar. super sexy of them.

bring it - seriously i know that svt and ptg are from the same era but this really reminds me of do it for fun by ptg's rap unit

wait 날 쏘고 가라?? why???

lilili yabbay - ok apparently linden has something to say to me about this song but it's really sexy?? i love the way it opens with the guitars and gradually turns into something more edm-esque

side note about minghao's voice - it's not really the voice you would expect from him? which is what makes it super cool imo

trauma - ok i'm actually fuming at svt hip hop team here because the lyrics are genuinely impactful and deep but the song is just. like. this is the biggest case of lyrics-beat mismatch i've come across so far i think

i wish hip hop team a very i hope you're ok

pinwheel - oh god. tenderness? this early in the day?

flower - oh that is a Song. funky as hell! love it!

rocket - build a rocket with you? uhhh maybe if it's made from milk cartons?

hello - what do you mean this isn't the shinee song

this is just a fun bouncy little song! i enjoy it a lot!

campfire - i heard 너를 닮은 날씨 and 꽃길... nice aju nice by seventeen reference haha

real talk though i would like to request svt to stop making songs about youth or i will simply have to Yearn

STOP offering to be my strength when i'm tired. STOP offering to hold my hand. i will CRY.

outro incompletion - oh nice incorporation of the clap instrumental! i do enjoy it when tracks on an album reference each other

thinkin' about you - the lyrics are cute!! the music is not necessarily my style but nice to know what svt are thinking about (you)

thanks - [sigh]

when will svt release their woof woof i am tired of sincerity

run to you - omg which anime is this for

seriously when will the svt x oldcodex collab happen i want answers

falling for u - i want to run a small cafe solely because i want to play this song over the speakers and watch as my customers find their coffee shop au fantasy

kind of love (seungkwan) - ohhhhhhhhh dear. oh boy. oh no.

just do it - they call us booseoksoon!!!!!!!!

those are some funky funny boys. i enjoy this a heck of a lot. particularly where they mentioned yangnyum chicken seemingly out of nowhere

missed connections (dokyeom) - oh COME ON.

what i love about dokyeom is that sometimes his voice doesn't sound like his voice? like there are points where he uses breath and dynamics in a way that he sounds like a completely different person from the one who did the high notes in aju nice. it's hard to explain without +

an example though.
anyway screw this i didn't expect to feel things

call call call - this is actually such a cool song i really enjoy it. feels like a song from a movie about race cars.

actually i'm going to be bold and say it. this is what jopping could have been.

not sure how i got to that thought for some reason i was thinking call call call -> race cars -> jopping ???

gonna skip the jpn versions of the songs i've already heard sorry

oh my! - summer bop???? love the random appearances of piano

holiday - another summer bop!!!

come to me - the music is not my style for some reason but i like that it fits the general vibe of 'we are having fun this summer and the knowledge of autumn coming won't stop us'

the second verse starts in a very nice way. good melodies!

what's good - slightly scary that svt know my preferred method of music listening is to put one song on repeat for several hours. vernon did you somehow see into the future when i listened to 'sickness by vernon' for a very long time on repeat

anyway! very bouncy. love the beat but i swear to god svt better stop with the "youth" songs. we are in the middle of a global pastrami.

moonwalker - oh i enjoy this!!!! this is the kind of song that i enjoy but i'm not happy about it... i'm like this with all house songs don't worry but i think this is exacerbated by the fact that the song's called moonwalker

what do you mean you're walking on the moon?!

anyway this fits in with the general gay house song category. see also: view by shinee, stay tonight by chungha, free somebody by luna, my show by cha ji yeon

our dawn is hotter than day - songs i thought about while listening to this song: smile flower (우슴꽃), good evening (달빛)

this song is also plenty good in its own right though... very summer...

i think if i were to sum up seventeen's vibe in a sentence it would be the feeling of enjoying a long summer night that's tinged with the ache of everything being temporary

a-teen - this is such a good song??????? i enjoy it????? a lot?????

bumaye remix (feat. vernon) - DRUNKEN TIGER AND BIZZY FEAT. VERNON?!!?!?!??!?!

the song is good i very much i enjoy it !!

it's been 5 hours but what the hell. 'i very much i enjoy it'? clearly the force of vernon x drunken tiger rendered me incapable of grammar

good to me - oh god this is such a song

they sing????? man this is wild

home - what do you mean this isn't the bts song

anyway this is music !!! very nice i appreciate it

hug - Man, Sure Is Great That I Am Invulnerable To Human Emotion!

chilli - saw this song title and i was like "this is going to be noise music". glad to say it is not! but then i was confused as to what this song could possibly be about. well friends i am happy to inform you that it fits with svt's usual vibe of 'having fun with your bros'

shhh - i love it when a song really confuses me!

getting closer - ...to what, exactly?

9-teen - oh no is this another song about how fun youth is

happy ending - oh i really enjoy this song!! loving the guitar :3

side note for some reason dokyeom really sounds like baekhyun in this song? in the best possible way like holy shit collab when

looped up (feat. vernon) - loop metaphors??? hoop metaphors????

ok haha this is a little. yeah

hansol vernon chwe send tweet

hit - i don't 'think' anything actually

lie again - ooooh i enjoy this song. i think it's a breakup song but i'm choosing to ignore that

fear - i swear i've heard this song before?? anyway no complaints it's a good song

let me hear you say -

247 - ahhhhhhh more cafe music from svt! carry on, i enjoy this

second life - oh great, more feelings. i thought this song was going to discuss the various theories on transmigration of the soul? honestly.

network love - how dare svt make me confront my conflicting feelings about house music

back it up - this belongs with nct's firetruck as songs that are just utterly incomprehensible

lucky - two thoughts crossed my mind as i listened to this song
1) this song is gay
2) this sounds like shinee
take from that what you will

hello. so it's been a while. i really did want to continue this thread yesterday but i ended up listening to sickness by vernon on repeat instead (you know what that song does to me) so here i am now!

snap shoot - oh i enjoy this. quite funky and unexpected at times

miracle (woozi) - oh dear i have a feeling this is going to be tender. is that really necessary? why can't we just go back to hit

sweetest thing - more tenderness?

fallin' flower - myri goes crazy for this song and they're so right i think it's very good....... watashi wa hana indeed

fearless - oh this FUCKS. this is MUSIC.

god i wanna be fearless eh oh eh oh so bad

left & right - hear me out: this feels like the opening for a disney channel teen sitcom.

like it's a very good song but it also feels like it could be the opening for wizards of waverly place, you know?

i wish - oh i do enjoy those vibes. i personally love when the opening of a song makes my mouth literally fall open so this is a good one i think

kind of reminds me of still i miss you by infinite in a way?? i think because of the shift in the chorus??

my my - ok no you can't have a song called my my And a song called oh my. that's just greedy.

kidult - OH nice. i like it when boys sing well.

together - i like it in songs when the music rests for a bit and the singers just sing and clap a beat it's nice

heng:garae might be my fav album so far? as yet undecided though, i'll need to properly register the discography first

no seriously when will seventeen and oldcodex collab

dream (jun) - tenderness? again? right now? in my emotionally fragile state?

jun's voice is so lovely though ;;

maze (the8) - oh i can't even say anything funny about this. this is just lovely. you go mighao

go - mr boo seungkwan do not make me think about youth on this fine day please

24h: OH THE CHORUS SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN ALLOWED TO DO THAT. OH THAT'S VERY CLEVER.

going from normal rhythm to swing rhythm like that is just grrrrrr

17 - i've been meaning to listen to pink sweats anyway so this is as good a way to start as any

LOVE that the song starts with josh singing in korean. that's a very bold move for a feature.

ok i like r&b a lot (you all know this) so this is very much a dream for me. very tender lyrics too

OK the combination of dokyeom and joshua's quite classically Kpop Trained Voices with mr pink sweats' soulful r&b-style voice is really working for me ahhhh i like it a lot

home;run - well that vibe change was unexpected but i really like this song so i'll forgive it

got a bit of a jazz influence which i definitely appreciate

feels like they're returning to their adore u roots

do re mi - OH this song came up on amazing saturday so i've heard bits of it before!! i appreciate the vibes of it, feels very typical of svt

hey buddy - you've got the bass? cool can i have it back now thanks

LOVING the funky feeling of this song. dare i say bruno mars-esque. keep going boys.

light a flame - OH WE'RE DOING A TANGO?! WE'RE DOING A TANGO RIGHT NOW?!

god i absolutely love the incorporation of different genres

wait are they literally talking about despacito that's amazing

ah! love - very smooth vibes i really like this

all my love - this feels very much like a return to the concept of the Joy Of Youth which hurts a little right now but the sounds are good

wen junhui?!?!?! https://open.spotify.com/track/7fTc6aBevhBfM6vjSQuWHZ?si=0399160303604f0c

gentle ballads are not what i would have expected from jun's solo repertoire but wow is he good at them

just looked at the lyrics and ????? wow ?????

once again: wen junhui!??!?!?! https://open.spotify.com/track/2PVzGmdezOMtKi0l8c3On3?si=17f5cb5cafec4c01

spider (hoshi) - grrrrrr who gave him the right. booooo who said you could make good sexy music

don't think i'll ever be able to think about this song without thinking of jenna's line-by-line translation and analysis. they're so clever. so's hoshi actually. and woozi and bumzu. so many clever people!

hang on i don't think i've mentioned that hoshi's voice is so not what i expected it to be?? like it has a kind of roughness to it sometimes which is a pleasant surprise but he can also sing high (see spider intro).

also i think he brings out the meaning of the lyrics really well. i Really Love the way he sings the 숨이 막힌다고. also the guitars!!! congratulations hoshi for making the only song!!!

side by side (korean ver.) - god i love the bit where he says numbers

hitori janai??? anyway i really enjoy this even if it does make me Wistful For Youth https://open.spotify.com/track/0zNo6vxprHTeiFXNTo65ga?si=b21878182afc4499

that's all, folks! thanks for sticking with me, can't wait to add to this thread!