Read on Twitter
1/
Masks don’t work to stop COVID, though they work wonders keeping kids out of school & unemployment high
But WHY don’t they work? Let’s see
Rather than thinking of respiratory aerosols like tiny spit globules, a better metaphor is cigarette smoke
https://twitter.com/Emily_Burns_V/status/1377064164091437060
Masks don’t work to stop COVID, though they work wonders keeping kids out of school & unemployment high
But WHY don’t they work? Let’s see
Rather than thinking of respiratory aerosols like tiny spit globules, a better metaphor is cigarette smoke
https://twitter.com/Emily_Burns_V/status/1377064164091437060
2/
Cigarette smoke is almost the exact same size as 99% of virus-carrying breath aerosols-- <1 micron. The majority of these particles are in the 0.2 – 0.25 micron range--just like the majority of breath aerosols.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/0095852260900374#:~:text=From%20these%20measurements%20it%20was,between%200.2%20and%200.25%20micron
Cigarette smoke is almost the exact same size as 99% of virus-carrying breath aerosols-- <1 micron. The majority of these particles are in the 0.2 – 0.25 micron range--just like the majority of breath aerosols.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/0095852260900374#:~:text=From%20these%20measurements%20it%20was,between%200.2%20and%200.25%20micron
3/
This is the EXACT range of breath aerosols. The chart below shows that out of around 11K breath aerosols generated during 5” of breathing, only about 25 are over 1 micron~0.02%. 90% are <0.3 microns—the exact same size & distribution as cigarette smoke.
https://www.pnas.org/content/118/8/e2021830118
This is the EXACT range of breath aerosols. The chart below shows that out of around 11K breath aerosols generated during 5” of breathing, only about 25 are over 1 micron~0.02%. 90% are <0.3 microns—the exact same size & distribution as cigarette smoke.
https://www.pnas.org/content/118/8/e2021830118
4/
Rather than thinking of the breath aerosols as being forced THROUGH the mask, it’s better to think of the mask as being non-porous—a barrier that redirects the aerosols. They aren’t filtered, b/c the force of exhalation pushes them out the nearest gap
Rather than thinking of the breath aerosols as being forced THROUGH the mask, it’s better to think of the mask as being non-porous—a barrier that redirects the aerosols. They aren’t filtered, b/c the force of exhalation pushes them out the nearest gap
5/
Way back in 2008, they found that only 0.1% of virus-carrying aerosols were larger than 5 microns, and that 87% of the virus was carried in particles <1 micron—which happens to map exactly to the size distribution of aerosols
https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0002691
Way back in 2008, they found that only 0.1% of virus-carrying aerosols were larger than 5 microns, and that 87% of the virus was carried in particles <1 micron—which happens to map exactly to the size distribution of aerosols
https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0002691
6/
There has been this idea that masks must help a little, because they filter at least the larger aerosols. If there were an even distribution of aerosols by size, this would make sense. But it’s not. There are 100x more aerosols <1 micron than over.
https://www.pnas.org/content/118/8/e2021830118
There has been this idea that masks must help a little, because they filter at least the larger aerosols. If there were an even distribution of aerosols by size, this would make sense. But it’s not. There are 100x more aerosols <1 micron than over.
https://www.pnas.org/content/118/8/e2021830118
7/
Additionally, we see that when the viral load peaks, around 7 days, aerosols <0.3 microns increase by 10-fold—to almost 100K. And those over 1 micron drop below 10. https://www.pnas.org/content/118/8/e2021830118
Additionally, we see that when the viral load peaks, around 7 days, aerosols <0.3 microns increase by 10-fold—to almost 100K. And those over 1 micron drop below 10. https://www.pnas.org/content/118/8/e2021830118
8/
The going theory is that this change occurs due to inflammation of the alveoli. This might explain why asymptomatic people infect others @ a lower rate (~0.7% vs. ~18%) b/c presumably, lacking inflammation, they would generate 10x fewer aerosols.
https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2774102?fbclid=IwAR3vVRho5wmJDDuwvlxOUnIoSpVGaV2AIoPX7rEa_TtLmNVtVMxopnM8XdE
The going theory is that this change occurs due to inflammation of the alveoli. This might explain why asymptomatic people infect others @ a lower rate (~0.7% vs. ~18%) b/c presumably, lacking inflammation, they would generate 10x fewer aerosols.
https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2774102?fbclid=IwAR3vVRho5wmJDDuwvlxOUnIoSpVGaV2AIoPX7rEa_TtLmNVtVMxopnM8XdE
9/
What you just witnessed is actually consistent with mechanistic studies that show that various masks CAN help to slow the spread. Those studies show that even an N-95 drops down to ~12% efficacy with only a 1% gap (equivalent to 1 mm on the sides).
https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acsnano.0c03252
What you just witnessed is actually consistent with mechanistic studies that show that various masks CAN help to slow the spread. Those studies show that even an N-95 drops down to ~12% efficacy with only a 1% gap (equivalent to 1 mm on the sides).
https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acsnano.0c03252
10/
Let’s look at a non-fit-tested KN-95. I tried to make it a close fit, but as you can see, the smoke still goes right out the top.
Let’s look at a non-fit-tested KN-95. I tried to make it a close fit, but as you can see, the smoke still goes right out the top.
11/
While doing this, I found that when I inhaled, due to the negative pressure created, I felt the seal tighten, where exhaling I could feel the breath forcing through the gaps. This may explain why N-95s help to protect, but don’t seem to impact transmission.
While doing this, I found that when I inhaled, due to the negative pressure created, I felt the seal tighten, where exhaling I could feel the breath forcing through the gaps. This may explain why N-95s help to protect, but don’t seem to impact transmission.
12/
The CDC has recently recommended double-masking—no doubt inspired by the mechanistic study performed by ACS referenced above.
Let’s try that, and see if that helps to keep the cigarette smoke in (which again, is the same size as respiratory aerosols).
The CDC has recently recommended double-masking—no doubt inspired by the mechanistic study performed by ACS referenced above.
Let’s try that, and see if that helps to keep the cigarette smoke in (which again, is the same size as respiratory aerosols).
13/
Why though? In the study, the CDC notes that double masking captured 87% of respiratory aerosols. The size range was 0.01 micron to 7 microns. Here’s the problem. The measured the VOLUME of the aerosols captured. https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/wr/mm7007e1.htm
Why though? In the study, the CDC notes that double masking captured 87% of respiratory aerosols. The size range was 0.01 micron to 7 microns. Here’s the problem. The measured the VOLUME of the aerosols captured. https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/wr/mm7007e1.htm
14/
The volume of a 7 micron aerosol is 12,000 times more than the volume of a 0.3 micron aerosol. So while aerosols over 1 micron make up less than 0.1%, and carry less than 0.1% of the virus, they make up 93% of the VOLUME of aerosols generated.
The volume of a 7 micron aerosol is 12,000 times more than the volume of a 0.3 micron aerosol. So while aerosols over 1 micron make up less than 0.1%, and carry less than 0.1% of the virus, they make up 93% of the VOLUME of aerosols generated.
15/
Which is these mechanistic studies are so flawed—and indeed why clinical trials have shown repeatedly that in real life, masks do not work to impact viral transmission.
https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/26/5/19-0994_article?fbclid=IwAR0B5G7uCEL5gOKB989joPmiH75VfzGsFdlUl0QSIsd3wET3uxGZl7Bf120
Which is these mechanistic studies are so flawed—and indeed why clinical trials have shown repeatedly that in real life, masks do not work to impact viral transmission.
https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/26/5/19-0994_article?fbclid=IwAR0B5G7uCEL5gOKB989joPmiH75VfzGsFdlUl0QSIsd3wET3uxGZl7Bf120
16/
None of this should have come as a surprise. We have known this for decades. As far back as 1980, a very elegant experiment placed a tracer particle on the inside of a surgical mask. EVERY SINGLE TIME the particle was found IN the wound.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7379387/
None of this should have come as a surprise. We have known this for decades. As far back as 1980, a very elegant experiment placed a tracer particle on the inside of a surgical mask. EVERY SINGLE TIME the particle was found IN the wound.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7379387/
17/
A 2016 review noted that even in for their main purpose—decreasing wound infection during surgery—surgical masks have no impact. But this purpose is to stop much larger particles than the smoke-sized aerosols that drive COVID transmission.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7138271/#:~:text=All%20three%20studies%20showed%20that,wound%20infections%20developing%20after%20surgery.
A 2016 review noted that even in for their main purpose—decreasing wound infection during surgery—surgical masks have no impact. But this purpose is to stop much larger particles than the smoke-sized aerosols that drive COVID transmission.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7138271/#:~:text=All%20three%20studies%20showed%20that,wound%20infections%20developing%20after%20surgery.
18/
The breath aerosols that drive transmission of COVID and other respiratory viruses are virtually un-filterable
https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/jamp.2020.1616
The breath aerosols that drive transmission of COVID and other respiratory viruses are virtually un-filterable
https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/10.1089/jamp.2020.1616
19/
Which explains why even N-95s, while again, showing good mechanistic data, do not appear to have an impact on actually reducing illness.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23418400/
Which explains why even N-95s, while again, showing good mechanistic data, do not appear to have an impact on actually reducing illness.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23418400/
20/
It is for this reason that people who are serious have raised alarms about the ability of N-95s to protect healthcare worker, and who have given voice to the importance of ventilation.
It is for this reason that people who are serious have raised alarms about the ability of N-95s to protect healthcare worker, and who have given voice to the importance of ventilation.
21/
Ultimately, just like incessant sanitizing to remove fomites, the 6 feet rule, etc. masks are just another part of the pandemic theater which seems to be the CDC’s raison d’être, creating panic to justify its existence. https://www.yahoo.com/now/end-the-hygiene-theater-cdc-says-173440864.html
Ultimately, just like incessant sanitizing to remove fomites, the 6 feet rule, etc. masks are just another part of the pandemic theater which seems to be the CDC’s raison d’être, creating panic to justify its existence. https://www.yahoo.com/now/end-the-hygiene-theater-cdc-says-173440864.html
22/
Now as the pandemic recedes, it is fear that is the pandemic.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4868614/
Now as the pandemic recedes, it is fear that is the pandemic.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4868614/
23/
Masks have become a symbol of right-think, no doubt why masking has its highest correlation with BLM support. But at the same time, the fear that masks symbolize cause acute harms—low in-person education and high unemployment. https://twitter.com/Emily_Burns_V/status/1377066067122655233
Masks have become a symbol of right-think, no doubt why masking has its highest correlation with BLM support. But at the same time, the fear that masks symbolize cause acute harms—low in-person education and high unemployment. https://twitter.com/Emily_Burns_V/status/1377066067122655233
24/
At the same time, these policies, supported most vocally by those in states who claim to care about social justice, result in kids in districts with high minority enrollment being educated 100% virtually at ~4-5x the rate as largely white districts.
At the same time, these policies, supported most vocally by those in states who claim to care about social justice, result in kids in districts with high minority enrollment being educated 100% virtually at ~4-5x the rate as largely white districts.
25/
The harm does not stop there.
Masking is associated with significant increases in fear of illness, physical isolation, and feeling isolated.
The harm does not stop there.
Masking is associated with significant increases in fear of illness, physical isolation, and feeling isolated.
26/
All to no end. It is time for the CDC to end this theatre as well. Every day that this dissonance between these measures and reality continues, medicine, public health and the government lose credibility. Every day it continues, people are harmed. https://twitter.com/Emily_Burns_V/status/1377066921733070848
All to no end. It is time for the CDC to end this theatre as well. Every day that this dissonance between these measures and reality continues, medicine, public health and the government lose credibility. Every day it continues, people are harmed. https://twitter.com/Emily_Burns_V/status/1377066921733070848
27/
The CDC has plenty of news it can share to calm people’s fears, but it chooses not to. This choice is leading many to question its motives for not doing so. https://www.thesmileproject.global/post/un-masking-children-part-2-of-4-understanding-relative-risk
The CDC has plenty of news it can share to calm people’s fears, but it chooses not to. This choice is leading many to question its motives for not doing so. https://www.thesmileproject.global/post/un-masking-children-part-2-of-4-understanding-relative-risk
28/
People DO believe that doctors and public health officials are smart. Thus, “incompetence” is not the answer they arrive at. They begin to suspect sinister motives—this is how conspiracy theories are planted and nurtured.
People DO believe that doctors and public health officials are smart. Thus, “incompetence” is not the answer they arrive at. They begin to suspect sinister motives—this is how conspiracy theories are planted and nurtured.
29/
It would be far better for American Public Health to acknowledge their failures. Doing so would actually work to create far more trust in them than the pointless dissembling that is occurring now.
It would be far better for American Public Health to acknowledge their failures. Doing so would actually work to create far more trust in them than the pointless dissembling that is occurring now.
30/
Of the many, many failures of American Public Health throughout this pandemic, few actions are more disgusting than the deliberate shifting of blame for their failed policies onto the American Public itself.
Of the many, many failures of American Public Health throughout this pandemic, few actions are more disgusting than the deliberate shifting of blame for their failed policies onto the American Public itself.
31/
The deliberate demonization of those who point to the manifest inefficacy of their policies is causing real moral corrosion of the populace. It is unthinkable that any public health establishment would stoke this kind of dehumanization of the public it "serves."
The deliberate demonization of those who point to the manifest inefficacy of their policies is causing real moral corrosion of the populace. It is unthinkable that any public health establishment would stoke this kind of dehumanization of the public it "serves."
32/
The vaccines work, and they work extraordinarily well at protecting those who are at real risk. Those people are almost all vaccinated at this point. It is time to be done with these pointless restrictions—especially the masks.
The vaccines work, and they work extraordinarily well at protecting those who are at real risk. Those people are almost all vaccinated at this point. It is time to be done with these pointless restrictions—especially the masks.
