NEW THREAD “What If...” is a fun little hypothetical game that I love to play (though it truly annoys my boyfriend ) And with #LoveIslandUSA I often think about what if every islander ended up with the person they initially coupled with or connected with?

Well, in this thread, I ponder what it would have looked like if that did in fact happen. So, let’s go! #LoveIslandUSA

1) Our very first #LoveIslandUSA S2 couple was Jeremiah and Cely. Jeremiah’s fun southern personality and Cely’s goofy charm might have worked well together, but I get the sense that it would have slid into a “better as friends” zone.