I mean, I am not denying that people of lower social status can suffer physically from their fate, but arguably. people of higher status can have crushed vertebrae too, for whatever reason.
Also, you cannot use a 'warm woollen cloak' to identify someone as a wealthy individual.
I am by no means saying that the interpretation is impossible, but it reveals much more of the way we look at the ancient evidence, than of the evidence itself.
We think of Rome as a world of slaves and aristocrats, hence we think we find slaves and aristocrats. I think we need a larger number of dimensions here.
Also, one other thing, which we just discussed here as a household full of Pompeii expertise: I do have an ethical problem with these pictures of, essentially, dead people.
We had long discussions about this standing at the Orto degli Fuggiaschi, which one of us abhorred, and I became convinced that the lives and deaths of these people should be honoured, and should not be exposed in this way. Particularly not on the internet.
I mean, if it were me, I could not care less. But these people are not me. They had their own mortal lives, and we need to respect that. I don't think these pictures are very respectful.
You can follow @drflohr.
Tip: mention @twtextapp on a Twitter thread with the keyword “unroll” to get a link to it.

Latest Threads Unrolled: