Read on Twitter
As Victorians breathe a well deserved sigh of relief this weekend, having smashed 2nd wave in world beating fashion, I wanted to talk about the way simplified media narratives have misled public about how dangerous âliving alongside covidâ is. News is meant to inform. A thread
Once media set a narrative to explain something - like Victorian second wave - they jump on it as a pack. Pack journalism reinforces and simplifies the dominant narrative so that only info that fits the narrative is included, and everything else is ignored. Journos are blinkered.
We all know what the simplified Vic covid narrative was - letâs call it âget Andrewsâ. There were two things used to explain covid spread - hotel quarantine infection and bad contact tracing. Thatâs it. Nothing else could permeate this simplistic narrative. It became entrenched.
This was of course a POLITICAL narrative. Inspired by Morrison and promoted by partisan Murdoch media, other outlets including Costelloâs Fairfax and âplease donât cut our fundingâ ABC obediently latched onto this simplistic âthis explains everythingâ narrative, blind to all else
I called out the simplified and distorting âVictoria contact tracing is badâ narrative back in August. As predicted, since then the narrative has continued without pause all the way up to today, ignoring all else. So has the obsession with security guards catching covid at HQ. https://twitter.com/vic_rollison/status/1298417422467133441
So, what was missed in rabidly simplified âget Andrewsâ narrative? There were lots of things missed - the spread of a pandemic is one of the most complex things you could imagine, and canât be blamed on ONE THING. Even when media reported other things, it never changed narrative.
By missing all these other factors, media distorted reporting and commentary of the pandemic by telling the public âif only virus didnât get out of hotel quarantine and if only Victoria could contact trace, Australia can live alongside virusâ. Thatâs a dangerous simplification.
Letâs look at some of the key info missed from âget Andrewsâ narrative. First, the obvious one. Look beyond the Victorian political blinkers at what was happening overseas with covid. There was no space in this narrative to compare Australian covid to horror happening overseas.
Because there was no comparison with overseas, there was never space in this narrative to analyse HOW and WHY covid was exponentially multiplying in other countries. Thatâs of course what viruses do - despite contact tracing, despite mask wearing and various other restrictions.
If journos had done this analysis, they would have found factors playing out overseas which also helped explain how Victoriaâs second wave happened. By doing this, theyâre actually presenting useful information to the public - everyone trying to deal with it - business and people
For example, from what Sutton has said, soon after covid got out of HQ (via night manager - a fact often missed in get-Andrews narrative), there was a super spreader event. This is the ultimate wrong place wrong time scenario - down to bad luck. This can seed hundreds of cases.
Scientists are still learning about how covid spreads. This helps to explain what theyâve learned - some cases donât spread to others, others spread to many if they are particularly contagious and coughing or sneezing in a crowded unventilated space. https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2020/09/k-overlooked-variable-driving-pandemic/616548/
helps to explain what theyâve learned - some cases donât spread to others, others spread to many if they are particularly contagious and coughing or sneezing in a crowded unventilated space. https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2020/09/k-overlooked-variable-driving-pandemic/616548/
Weâve seen the super spreader event happen at Chadstone butcher shop. Weâve seen it happen at Liverpool hospital - first cases showed up in August and that cluster has had new cases two months later. Now imagine such an event happened in Victoria without contact tracers knowing.
Once undetected spread is out there, it can multiply exponentially. Some unknown cases might show up and others might keep spreading without testing. This is randomness of pandemic. Undetected spread from super spreader was - in my opinion - how covid got away from Victorian govt
Add to this, the second wave, as weâve known for months, is far more contagious than the first wave. This is crucial context to understand when looking at the impact of a super spreader event. Within weeks, hundreds will infect thousands. https://abc13.com/new-coronavirus-mutation-spreads-faster-is-not-more-deadly-what-we-know-about-covid-19-strand/6543822/
Other key fact missing in analysis of 2nd wave - particularly obsessive focus on blaming Andrews for security guards catching covid, is we now know covid is airborne. We know that, yet Morrisonâs health dept havenât updated health advice to make this clear https://idp.nature.com/transit?redirect_uri=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nature.com%2Farticles%2Fd41586-020-02058-1&code=302c7c72-dcaa-4f76-ba40-5d4d4fa4ed0c
The other thing missing in get-Andrews constant criticism of contact tracing is just how difficult contact tracing is when youâve got tens of cases a day. The politicised narrative kept comparing NSW contact tracing to Victoriaâs, but obviously itâs harder when thousands to trace https://twitter.com/matt_hopcraft/status/1316331587898757122
Once the narrative was fixed - Victoria canât contact trace, full stop, case closed - journos then failed to ever analyse what a GOOD job Vic contact tracers were doing. Even when experts said âthis is great workâ, the get-Andrews narrative couldnât accomodate this info. https://twitter.com/stephenjduckett/status/1316970328975953920
Also missing from obsession with contact tracing is that you can trace cases you donât know about. Today Age reporting (well!) that Vic health felt are acknowledging low testing let covid spread get away from them. https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/victoria-failed-to-test-enough-when-second-wave-seeded-testing-chief-20201016-p565sj.html
So crucial to talk about how the policy - which exists in every state currently - of asking people to come forward for testing âif you have symptomsâ is missing a huge number of cases. In late June, Vic govt went looking for undetected spread and found it - hundreds of cases.
There is no doubt NSW Health have been doing a good job of managing covid, but even despite this, theyâve still had undetected spread and unknown cases popping up. NSW CHO said latest cases show there have been âweeks or monthsâ of missed transmission. https://thenewdaily.com.au/news/coronavirus/2020/10/14/nsw-case-spike-restrictions/
The simplified narrative blaming Vic HQ and contact tracing for second wave, coupled with the âweâve got thisâ NSW narrative (eg. gold standard contact tracing) has, in my opinion, lulled NSW into a false sense of security, which explains dangerously low testing numbers in NSW.
Another huge factor missing from the âget-Andrewsâ narrative is the risk and consequences of asymptomatic spread. A study in this article says UK have had double or even triple positive cases due to asymptomatic cases not getting tested.
https://theconversation.com/europes-second-wave-is-worse-than-the-first-what-went-so-wrong-and-what-can-it-learn-from-countries-like-vietnam-147907
https://theconversation.com/europes-second-wave-is-worse-than-the-first-what-went-so-wrong-and-what-can-it-learn-from-countries-like-vietnam-147907
The other danger of asymptomatic spread is itâs most likely to occur in young people who are also the group most likely to ignore restrictions like social distancing because theyâre not scared of catching covid. Morrison always said schools were safe. That is clearly not true.
Young people circulating with the virus undetected is being blamed for covid getting away from Scotland. They had very low numbers -0-10 every day for weeks, and they now suspect this number hid huge outbreaks amongst 18-30 year olds. https://www.heraldscotland.com/news/18708703.coronavirus-scotland-truth-covid-rates-young-people-hospital-admissions-conundrum/
But wait, thereâs more. We of course know that itâs not just asymptomatic cases which lead people not to get tested. People with symptoms also donât always get tested for various reasons - casual work, fear of stigma, impact on family. This fact is missing https://www.theage.com.au/politics/victoria/how-covid-19-stigma-is-turning-victorians-away-from-testing-20200819-p55n84.html
We have also known throughout second wave that even when people get tested they donât always work productively with contact tracers to map their whereabouts. They donât always answer their phone, nor be honest about where theyâve been. Theyâre human.
Even when such facts are known - when Vic DHHS said positive case didnât disclose visit to Shepparton - rather than accepting the complexity of pandemic response is only as good as humans caught up in it, journos just used this as new way to âget Andrewsâ - blinkered by narrative
Iâm almost finished. Other part of get-Andrews narrative which has been simplified is the role of police. To be blunt, there is no point having health restrictions if theyâre not policed. Happy for people to scrutinise police actions. Fact remains, they police powers were needed.
Additionally, missing from get-Andrews narrative was reasonable balanced scrutiny of the failure of Federal govt to manage areas of covid response theyâre responsible for - particularly aged care. They had no plan. And journos ignore this blatantly fact. https://theconversation.com/federal-departments-had-no-specific-covid-plan-for-aged-care-royal-commission-counsel-144204
All this simplification in the get-Andrews narrative has also meant that media has consistency framed covid lockdowns in Victoria as ONLY necessary because Andrews canât manage covid. This has led to mass opposition to lockdowns by media and in turn public, undermining confidence
It has been clear from start of lockdowns due to second wave, media were not going to accept that lockdowns were not only necessary, but were actually not the enemy or the villain - the virus was. This led to constant âpressureâ on Andrews, in concert with Libs, to open too early
Finally, the biggest elephant in the room missing from the get-Andrews narrative is the exceptional success Vic govt has had fighting the covid pandemic. They could never congratulate Vic for doing this because that doesnât fit the narrative. Thatâs it. Thanks for reading. End
because that doesnât fit the narrative. Thatâs it. Thanks for reading. End
