I cannot see what he wrote.

That primate blocked me after I exposed his lies.

If this rat is not afraid of the truth and does not fear getting exposed, I challenge him to unblock and debate me. But I doubt he would. He is extremely fraudulent and spineless https://twitter.com/Pawwlice/status/1317393203260055552
I had invited him to unblock me and have a debate with me. I had given him a time period of ten days. He has not dared to unblock and engage in a debate with me. Hence, I shall myself now examine his arguments and analyze whether there be a scintilla of truth in any of them.
The crux of his argument is his claim that Biryani allegedly "originated as a corruption of Pilaf".

He claims that the Pilaf is "Persian" and by implication its "corruption" Biryani is also foreign.
Now, he knows there is a problem when he takes this line of argument. The problem is the very veracity of his claim that Pilaf is Persian. He knows that it is contradicted by many prominent authors like food historian like KT Acharya who claim Pilaf is Indian in origin.
Ergo, he is only left with dismissing the works of those who say Pilaf is Indian in origin.

Hence, he brings out an "LA times review" that allegedly "shreds Acharya to smithereens".

https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1994-12-15-fo-9100-story.html
However, the review tells us more about the American LA Times reviewer Charles Perry and his utter lack of knowledge regarding Indian languages than anything else.
In his review, Charles Perry accuses Acharya of "inventing the myth of Pulav in Old Tamil". He says "Pulavu" only means raw meat. He says any meaning of rice dish is simply non existent in Tamil. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1994-12-15-fo-9100-story.html
This is exactly what I call a wild goose chase of a FOOL. Chasing something that simply is a product of his own imagination and does not exist in the first place!
Both Charles Perry and @Schandillia betray utter lack of BASIC Sanskrit knowledge

This is factually INCORRECT

There exists NO SUCH WORD as "Pulao" in Sanskrit .The word in question is Pulāka (पुलाक) meaning "boiled rice" (alternatively, it could also mean "shrivelled grain").
This Sanskrit word was taken into Old Tamil and Old Telugu as "Pulakam". And the word gave its name very famous rice dish named Pulakam that is extant even today in South India (புளகம், పులకము).

https://agarathi.com/word/%E0%AE%AA%E0%AF%81%E0%AE%B3%E0%AE%95%E0%AE%AE%E0%AF%8D
While Pulakam is mainly served today as a Khichdi like rice dish, some older regional variants particularly used spices, saffron and accompanied it with Rayta like curd preparation, making it identical to what is understood by "Pulav" today
But what is the evidence that Pulav/Pilaf comes from Pulāka /Pulakam ? We shall examine this question in the subsequent tweets
The great Persian linguist Ali Nourai shows that a sound cluster of voiceless plosive, non front vowel and a liquid is simply not existent in native Persian phonology

Hence, a word such as "Pilaw/pilaf" is simply NOT a native Persian word. It is a borrowed loanword into Persian
In his path-breaking magnum opus "The Etymology dictionary of Persian", The Persian Linguist Dr. Ali Nourai very clearly mentions that the Persian word "Pulav/Pilaw/Pilaf" comes from the Sanskrit word Pulāka.
In "Etymological Dictionary of Persian", leading Persian linguist
Garnik Asatrian makes a very interesting point.

He says the word "Pulav/Pilaw" or its ancestors are completely ABSENT in Old & Middle Persian. It occurs in New Persian when Ghaznavids begin expanding into India
Both the books trace the Persian "Pulav/Pilaf" to Sanskritic "Pulāka".

These are the only available comprehensive etymology dictionaries of Persian language incorporating new research from the field of Indo European linguistics
What does it tell us? A clueless American FOOL wrote a horrible review without any knowledge about Eastern languages and a chimpanzee @schandillia used it as THE ultimate truth in his garbage tweets.

Another FOOL promoted his tweets as the ultimate truth https://twitter.com/tehseenp/status/1317395294686830593
This thread will be continued
You can follow @TIinExile.
Tip: mention @twtextapp on a Twitter thread with the keyword “unroll” to get a link to it.

Latest Threads Unrolled: