Its time to ponder
A very important thread

I was thinking about something .So i thought its better to share with you...We know prophets have 4 daughters and 4 grandsons...But why we find فضائل about fatimah not other daughters..we find باب فضائل فاطمة but we donot find any chapter on فضائل of other daughters

Fatimah is called learder of women or paradise .Why not we find فضائل
about other daughters of prophet pbuh...We know that Zainab binte Muhammad bear more hardships than Fatimah binte Muhammad...I willl tell you about that

Zainab binte Muhammad lived without her husband for a long span of time...Imagine pain living without your beloved husband...She loved her husbsnd very much..when going towards medinah .She was injured badly hit by spear even prophet pbuh said she is my most beloved daughter

Prophet pbuh said to Zainab .She is my most beloved daughter and she was hurt because of me but we donot find any فضائل about her like fatimah...lets move forward about ayah of tatheer and hadith kissa..

According to some sources ayah of tatheer was revealed in aishah house and according to some it was revealed in Umm slamah house...It cannot be revealed in umm salmah house because Prophet pbuh said revealation only came to me in hijrah of aishah

So it could only be revealed at aishah house not umm salmah...Secondly Umm kulthum binte Muhammad and Zainab binte Muhammad both died in 8Ah and 9Ah respectively.Why they were not included in hadith of Kissah and Ali bin Al Ass also ..Were they not ahlul bayt..?

Why zainab and umm kulthum binte Muhammad and Ali bin abi Ass not included in hadith of kissa..They were alive at that time and were living in medinah...Why they were excluded..?Is there isnad of this hadith entirely consisting of people of medinah?

Because according to imam zuhri kufans used to lie a lot .He donot believe in their hadith generally...Now whenever we talk we say ازاوج and اھل بیت separately....Ajwaz are ahlul bayt also why we take their name separatly from ahlul bayt and آل محمد

Wives of prophet pbuh are بالا ولی ahul bayt and ال محمد...when we say پنجتن پاک why we forget wives other daughters sons and grandsons of prophet pbuh..Why this hypocrisy from us?

From narration of zaid bin Arqam people come to conclusion that sadaqah is not haram on wives of prophet..But zaid bin arqam is mistaken here...As he himself says he became very old and forget a lot of things...
Sadaqah was forbidden for wives of prophet pbuh..

In narration of sahih muslim when someone give somethings as a sadaqah to barrirah ...prophet pbuh wanted something to eat so aishah said it is sadaqah .Prophet replied it is sadaqah for barrirah not for us...implying prophet pbuh himself and aishah..

In a sahih narration of musanaf ibn sbi shahybah .Someone gave sadaqah to aishabh ..She replied sadaqah is forbidden for us...
So it proves sadaqah is forbidden for wives of Rasool Allah pbuh..zaid bin arqam was mistaken there..

Now we talk about grandsons they were four Hassan Hussayn Ali bin abi Ass and abdullah bin uthman...why we only find merits about hassan and hussayn not others..
Abdullah bin uthmaj died in 4 Ah was born in makkah but Ali bin abi Ass lived longer..

Ali bin Abi Ass was broughtup under care of prophet pbuh.He was 14 years old at conquest of makkah.He even sat on shoulder of prophet pbuh and broke the idols at
conquest of makkah.
Why we donot find any merit about him?According to some sources He died before death of prophet

But according to some sources Ali bin abi Ass died in battle of yarmuk..So why do we exclude him..Isn't this dishonesty from our side...???We only talk about some ahlul bayt and ignore others..

We find in our hadith sources Hassan and hussayn are learders of paradise of people of youth..I donot believe this to be true ..My intellect donot accept this..We find in authdntic ahadith reports that participants of badar and uhud are more afdhal than anyone else..

How hassan and hussayn can be leaders of participants or badar and uhud in jannah...Hassan and hussayn were barely seven years old when prophet pbuh died..They donot bear hardships during the time or prophet pbuh .But other sahabahs did

Quran praised Muhajreen and ansar ...They left their homes and were shaken badly and fought against relatives in badr and uhud and .What about ahsab صفا .They barely habe anything to eat ..Tey left their homes for cause or Islam and didnot have proper cothes to cover themselves

Ashab صفا even donot have proper clothes to cover themselves in salah.Imagine how they are living .How they were enduring hardships for sake of Islam..Imagine about ansar who distributed their wives wealth among muhajreen.They fought for prophet pbuh and provided shelter to them

Imagine معاز and معوز
Those who killed the abu jahal and they were also killed in battle ...Imagine about hijrah of حبشہ
Imagine about hardships of bilal ibn rabah ...Everyone knows about that..Can Hassn anf hussayn be leader of bilal ibn rabah in jannah I donot think so..

Hassan and Hussayn were 7 years old at death or prophet pbuh ..after that conquest were made khums csme from battles ...So life became easy after the conquest of syria and Iraq ..How they can be leader of ansar and muhajreen in jannah ? Just because merely of kinship?..

To me hassan and hussayn cannot be leaders of ansar and muhajreen .Because ansar and muhajreen have more services for Islam .Imagine about bilal ibn Rabbah hardships...?? We have to be honest ..

@makh4n @MurrahSays @AbdullahBiqai @EbnHussein1424 @h_sufia @Noor_as_Sunnah
Read the entire thread

@imshoaibi @_palaao Read the entire thread