This article is a perfect example of how the obsessive anti-trans cult recruit unsuspecting women into their ideology under the guise of âfeminismâ and a narrative of âwoman as victimâ.
Itâs deeply insidious, manipulative gaslighting...
Letâs pick it apart...
Thread/
Itâs deeply insidious, manipulative gaslighting...
Letâs pick it apart...
Thread/
To understand the article, you need to know the context.
Stella OâMalley is a well known anti-trans campaigner. She fronted the âTrans Kids: Itâs Time To Talkâ documentary in 2018, which was just one big dump on trans kids, and has been a committed transphobe ever since...
Stella OâMalley is a well known anti-trans campaigner. She fronted the âTrans Kids: Itâs Time To Talkâ documentary in 2018, which was just one big dump on trans kids, and has been a committed transphobe ever since...
As a result of Stella, and her âgender criticalâ cohorts, relentless, obsessive, and often deeply offensive campaigning against trans people and their equality, she has received push-back and criticism.
MUCH of that criticism has come from trans-inclusive cis women like me...
MUCH of that criticism has come from trans-inclusive cis women like me...
However, Stella and her trans-hostile âgender criticalâ cult (which are predominantly privileged, white, cis women) constantly ignore the MANY cis women speaking out against them and in support of trans rights - in favour of claiming theyâre being âsilencedâ by âmisogynistic menâ
This is where the first insidious dig comes in...
When Stella talks about âmenâ here, what sheâs actually referring to is trans womenâ. When she mentions âwomenâ - This is a particularly nasty dogwhistle that transphobes use to put down trans women in plain sight...
When Stella talks about âmenâ here, what sheâs actually referring to is trans womenâ. When she mentions âwomenâ - This is a particularly nasty dogwhistle that transphobes use to put down trans women in plain sight...
When Stella uses the word âwomenâ, sheâs desperately trying to make ALL women feel as though theyâre imminently under attack from âmenâ - Sheâs calling on the deeply internalised trope of âwoman as victimâ to rally the troops behind her cause...
Of course, what Stella conveniently fails to disclose, is that âmenâ (what she calls trans women) donât âhateâ ALL women - they just detest the small group of privileged cis women who have dedicated their lives to hating trans people!...
Stella tries to further trigger women through evoking shared female trauma / experience, by mentioning feminist movements that have called out the patriarchal, misogynistic and unequal society in which we still live.
After all, nobody will dispute that, right?...
After all, nobody will dispute that, right?...
By aligning her transphobic narrative with feminist campaigns that are universally recognised and respected, Stella is trying to appropriate support through proximity - equating #MeToo
to #IStandWithJKRolling - THESE ARE NOT THE SAME!...

#MeToo
was a social movement recognising the number of women who have been abused by men
#IStandWithJKRolling is a response to JK Rowling using her extraordinarily influential platform to attack trans people, and her being called out for it!...

#IStandWithJKRolling is a response to JK Rowling using her extraordinarily influential platform to attack trans people, and her being called out for it!...
Conflating the abuse that everyday women get AS A RESULT OF BEING WOMEN, and the abuse JK Rowling has received AS A RESULT OF BEING A TRANSPHOBE are two completely different things.
Claiming JKR is âhatedâ because sheâs a woman is entirely disingenuous!...
Claiming JKR is âhatedâ because sheâs a woman is entirely disingenuous!...
What is incredibly ironic, is the conjuring up by an anti-trans campaigner of the #BeNice movement, in light of the fact so many âgender criticalâ transphobes frequently proudly declare âfuck niceâ and âIâm a feminist - not the nice kind!â...
Stella is right on one point - There are those who think âthe truth is not important; what is important is the cleverly worded burn and the prize is likes, shares and retweets.â - But this describes perfectly the obsessive âgender criticalâ campaigners, and troll chums...
What then follows is a stream of gaslighting - Everything Stella writes is intended as a âsales brochureâ to trigger womenâs anxieties to recruit them into the âgender criticalâ fold.
(Article behind paywall. Screenshots from Mumsnet)
(Article behind paywall. Screenshots from Mumsnet)
When you read this article through the lense of a piece of propaganda trying to recruit new members into the âgender criticalâ cult - Not as an âopinion pieceâ but as the first step of radicalisation into a hate group, you can start to see how insidious it is!...
In fact, much of Stellaâs article is a perfect example of DARVO - Deny, Attack, and Reverse Victim and Offender - Where those in power present themselves as the âvictimâ to gain sympathy and support.
This is excellently explained in this article
... https://metro.co.uk/2020/06/13/guide-darvo-gaslighting-response-people-give-when-called-bad-behaviour-12847680/
This is excellently explained in this article

This is a perfect example of white, cis, female privilege, putting DARVO into action.
Stella OâMalleyâs article is the written version of this - calling on the âwoman as victim that needs protectingâ trope to rally the troops against her intended target - trans people!
https://twitter.com/melodymcooper/status/1264965252866641920
Stella OâMalleyâs article is the written version of this - calling on the âwoman as victim that needs protectingâ trope to rally the troops against her intended target - trans people!
