Read on Twitter
New York compared with Liverpool: Schools
A Thread
A Thread
The @WSJ is reporting that
"New York City on Wednesday will close public schools and nonessential businesses in parts of Brooklyn and Queens that have registered a week-long spike in coronavirus cases" https://www.wsj.com/articles/new-york-city-to-close-schools-in-some-neighborhoods-due-to-rising-covid-cases-11601829614
"New York City on Wednesday will close public schools and nonessential businesses in parts of Brooklyn and Queens that have registered a week-long spike in coronavirus cases" https://www.wsj.com/articles/new-york-city-to-close-schools-in-some-neighborhoods-due-to-rising-covid-cases-11601829614
Let's look at New York and then compare to a UK city, Liverpool.
Cases are high in some New York boroughs. Up to 216 cases per 100,000 per week. But school closures are also being implemented in areas with 89 cases per 100,000 (source: NYT https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/nyregion/new-york-city-coronavirus-cases.html )
Let's compare with Liverpool. Here is the latest @PHE_uk report. Liverpool has cases of 238 cases per 100,000 in a week. Which is slightly higher than the highest rate ZIP code in NYC.
But remember, Liverpool's figures are for the whole local authority.
But remember, Liverpool's figures are for the whole local authority.
Let's look a little deeper into Liverpool. Here's the map. We can see some areas with incidence in excess of *1200* cases per 100,000. That's very high. And don't forget this is *detected* cases. The number of cases will be much higher.
But how do we know that there hasn't been enough testing? We look at positivity. Positivity is the number of people who test positive divided by the number of people tested.
And this is what NYC uses to determine whether schools should be closed. https://www.schools.nyc.gov/school-year-20-21/return-to-school-2020/health-and-safety
And this is what NYC uses to determine whether schools should be closed. https://www.schools.nyc.gov/school-year-20-21/return-to-school-2020/health-and-safety
If an area of NYC has positivity greater than 3% - three in every 100 tests being positive - then schools close.
What does positivity tell us? Whether enough tests are being performed.
What does positivity tell us? Whether enough tests are being performed.
"the World Health Organization recommended in May that the percent positive remain below 5% for at least two weeks before governments consider reopening." https://www.jhsph.edu/covid-19/articles/covid-19-testing-understanding-the-percent-positive.html
So, given that positivity is set at a threshold of 3% for school closures in NYC
and WHO suggest 5% before reopening, this begs the question -
What is the positivity in Liverpool?
and WHO suggest 5% before reopening, this begs the question -
What is the positivity in Liverpool?
Just under 15%, according to the latest published data (PHE week 40 reporting).
Which means that around 15% of all tests in Liverpool come back positive.
That's *very high*.
And means not enough testing is being carried out.
And this is a problem.
Which means that around 15% of all tests in Liverpool come back positive.
That's *very high*.
And means not enough testing is being carried out.
And this is a problem.
This is just an example of a city with large positivity. Extra testing capacity has been sent to Liverpool presumably due to students returning to universities there.
This is not a Liverpool problem - it's a national problem.
This is not a Liverpool problem - it's a national problem.
Please see my website for further information.
Happy to discuss with journalists. DMs open. http://www.duncanrobertson.com/2020/10/04/we-are-still-not-doing-enough-testing-a-case-study-of-new-york-and-liverpool-schools/
Happy to discuss with journalists. DMs open. http://www.duncanrobertson.com/2020/10/04/we-are-still-not-doing-enough-testing-a-case-study-of-new-york-and-liverpool-schools/
