I got crush on Deadly when I first saw her in Modern Warfare.
Such a stunning debut and a great example of a soldier is a soldier not a special token or something..... just my opinion.

No amputee or warpaint to differentiate from others to "emphasize" their "specialty", you know

That's why I love Alice so much.
She's no special token or something, she just blends in with her Demon Dog buddies instead of having to keep reminding everybody how "different" she is.
She belongs in Demon Dogs and that's who she is like other Demon Dogs.

Imagine if she was given to Modern Warfare or future warfare. Would people digest her well just because it wouldn't set in WW2?

I don't think so. Even if it was some sorta Captain Hook character, he wouldn't fit in.
The controversies were about "the recipe" not female soldiers.

Last of all folks, thanks for reading this thread all the way to the end and I really want to make sure this is solemnly my own opinion. I'm not here to judge others today, this is to express my side of analysis on what would work and what wouldn't.
Thanks again.