Diane Abbott won 18,912 votes - just 77 fewer votes than the Labour candidate 4 years earlier, though the Labour vote share was 49% rather than 52%. There was an increased turnout (+3.4%), with Oliver Letwin adding 800 votes and the Alliance candidate adding 1700 votes.
After one term as MP, Diane Abbott won 58% of vote in 1992, as LibDem and Conservative vote and vote-share fell, and turnout rose. (The academic evidence suggests small ethnic penalties for first-time candidates, which diminish or disappear for incumbents seeking re-election)
Hackney 1987 result supports hypothesis that "imputed prejudice" - selectorates fearing yet also exaggerating racial prejudice of voters - put significant brake on ethnic diversity in parliament esp 1983-2005 period, as Shamit Saggar argued in 2001
http://www.bbc.co.uk/otr/intext/20001008_film_1.html
Significantly exacerbated by a political/media folk memory (mythology) of Tory loss of Cheltenham in 1992, which is still misremembered/misreported by political classes as loss of a safe seat due to candidate being black. Which the evidence doesn't support
http://www.nextleft.org/2010/07/lord-taylor-and-myth-of-cheltenham-1992.html
Abbott was the only black female MP for a decade. Two black women were MPs in the 20th century. No Asian woman was an MP until 2010.

There are now 37 ethnic minority female MPs in 2020 (rising from just 3 in 2009), alongside 28 ethnic minority male MPs https://twitter.com/sundersays/status/1271123966145581058
Labour did select an Asian candidate, for a Tory-held by-election in 1991, in the 99% white British seat of Cleveland. Ashok Kumar won the seat, though the Conservatives regained it in the 1992 General Election
There seems to be little evidence of candidate ethnicity playing any significant role in that closely fought Red/Blue wall marginal in 1991-1992. Kumar then won the new Middlesbrough South seat in 1997.
Despite that, Labour now seldom selects non-white candidates in lower diversity seats

Cons breakthrough 2010-2019 includes ongoing reluctance to run non-white candidates in marginals. Black/Asian candidates in Conservative-held seats (usually low levels of ethnic diversity)
Transcript of On The Record package, Oct 2000, on barriers to ethnic diversity in politics, with 9 MPs out of 650 in the Blair era. Features Diane Abbott, Trevor Phillips, Oona King and Shamit Saggar.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/otr/intext/20001008_film_1.html
Overall, good evidence that *party colours* of candidate's rosette probably 50 times as important as the skin colour of a party candidate. Indeed, evidence is that was already true by the early '90s, though party activists, selectors & media elites lacked confidence in the voters
Elections - such as Hackney 1987, Cleveland 1991/92, the Gloucester Labour result in 2001 + partisan support for Cons candidates in low diversity seats in 2010-15 were therefore v important in establishing this, enabling ethnic diversity to become a 'new normal' in UK politics
You can follow @sundersays.
Tip: mention @twtextapp on a Twitter thread with the keyword “unroll” to get a link to it.

Latest Threads Unrolled: