Read on Twitter
Was Bhagat Singh an Atheist ?
My question on "Why i am an Atheist" , a book said to be written by Bhagat Singh
1. Bhagat singh was an Arya Samaji , came from an arya Samaji Family.
2. Same Bhagat Singh says in the book that एक आर्य समाजी और कुछ भी हो, नास्तिक नहीं होता।
My question on "Why i am an Atheist" , a book said to be written by Bhagat Singh
1. Bhagat singh was an Arya Samaji , came from an arya Samaji Family.
2. Same Bhagat Singh says in the book that एक आर्य समाजी और कुछ भी हो, नास्तिक नहीं होता।
3. The same line in original english. An Arya Samajist is anything but an atheist. source of both , hindi, english is this website
Eng- https://www.marxists.org/hindi/bhagat-singh/1931/main-nastik-kyon-hoon.htm
Hindi- https://www.marxists.org/archive/bhagat-singh/1930/10/05.htm
Eng- https://www.marxists.org/hindi/bhagat-singh/1931/main-nastik-kyon-hoon.htm
Hindi- https://www.marxists.org/archive/bhagat-singh/1930/10/05.htm
4. The book came 6 months after Bhagat Singh was Hanged.
5. Most important , the question raised on different belief , raises a question , why he did not raise any question on his own arya samaji belief ? did he ?
5. Most important , the question raised on different belief , raises a question , why he did not raise any question on his own arya samaji belief ? did he ?
6. For. Example Ex muslim will 1st raise question on is own belief , ex. christ , on christ belief , but if ex muslim , ex christ. raises question on others , and not his own belief , becomes questionable. Bhagat singh didn't raised any question on Arya Samaji Belief
7. The question he raised on Hinduism has already contain answer for an Arya Samaji , Even a Arya Samaji child can easily answer such questions. Bhagat Singh was very intelligent. i dont believe he raised such questions.
8. Book claims Bhagat singh studied every religious book , then definitely he read SatyarthPrakash(SP) as he was an Arya Samajist , BUT if you read his book you find he seems to be unaware of SP , This is easy to understand because of his questions that already answered BY SP
9. For Ex. he asks a questions on god being Omnipotent , Swami Dayanand has answered with such question , and cleared out the actual meaning of omnipotent. Bhagat Singh being an Arya Samaji obviously read SP , I dont think he will ask such question.
10. Bhagat Singh always visited Arya Samaj mandir for his activities , if he was a staunch communist , why he go to Kolkata Arya Samaj instead of Communists haunt of Kolkata.
11. Even Savarkar was an atheist but no communist try to promote him ? Why ?
11. Even Savarkar was an atheist but no communist try to promote him ? Why ?
At last Bhagat singh will still be hero for every Bhartiya , whether he is atheist or not, but those who only promote their agenda by portraying him as an atheist are questionable.
