Misogyny Is endorsed in Shiaism, proven from their most authentic Book; Usūl Al Kāfi

A THREAD

Misogyny is Harām. Although Allah has granted different rights to both genders as well as different responsibilities, The Deen teaches us to not undermine man or a woman. Yes, The Deen tells us man is better in some things, as are women. But we shouldn't degrade any of them

Rawafidh seem to think different.

Although many will claim they dont hold such beliefs, Muhammad Bin Ya'qūb Al Kulaynī seems to think otherwise. In his book of narrations Al Kāfi, he's gathered some ridiculous narrations.

Rawafidh take this as their most authentic book.

Even if a Rafidhi states they dont believe in these narrations, how do you know they're not practicing Taqiyyah?

Bear in mind, this is their most authentic book

I will focus on 2 chapters from this Book, which outlines The misogyny endorsed.

(1) Chapter of disciplining women

(2) Chapter of leaving their obedience (disobeying them)

(1) Vol 5, Ch 347 - 348you will find the following narrations:

1 - Do not abandon women in the rooms (which means continue having sex with them) & do not teach them to write, teach them to spin thread & Sūrah Nūr

(I will explain why Sūrah Nūr has been specified)

* So we see from this narration, we shouldn't teach them to write - technically every Shi'ee girl he went school & received formal education or any Shi'ee Teacher has gone against their Hadith - Also, its pretty convenient sex is allowed, how does that discipline anyone?

if anything its just there to fulfill the mans desires. Whats wrong with a woman writing? Is the preservation of The Deen solely for men? Did Fatimah RA know how to write? If she did, has she opposed The Messenger? *

2 - Why was Sūrah Nūr specified? lets go to the next narration:

Do not teach your women Sūrah Yūsuf & dont only read that to them, indeed there is Fitnah within it. And teach them Sūrah Nūr, indeed it holds good advice.

* So Ali RA supposedly spoke against teaching women The Qurān? And how can someone state The Qurān has Fitnah within? It has corruption within? That's Kufr.

So apparently Sūrah Yūsuf has fitnah, but Sūrah Nūr has advice.*

What does this mean?

What message is taught in both Sūrahs involving women?

Sūrah Yūsuf - Story of Zulaykha seducing Yūsuf AS = Fitnah

Sūrah Nūr - Punishment for Adultery, accusation of adultery & the commanding of women to cover up & who they can/can't make themselves apparent to = Good Advice

The issue here is, they're literally implying women are sexual deviants who will attempt to seduce men if they learn of Sūrah Yūsuf, but will stay in their lane if told of their punishment & restrictions, thus being labelled as sound advice.

This is disgusting & unjust

In addition, they slander Ali RA saying he spoke against teaching The Qurān.

Allah refers to The Qurān as Adh Dhikr, (The Reminder) yet Rawafidh label a Sūrah as a holder of Fitnah

(2) Lets move on to the second chapter & its narrations. Its literally a whole chapter dedicated to the virtue of disobeying women.

Why do you obey Fatimah RA for then?

Heres a list of a few narrations:

3- "Defy & disobey them (women) in goodness before they command you to do evil. And seek refuge in Allah from their evil and be wary/alert of their choices"

* I feel sorry for Al Kulaynī's wife *

A few narrations state the same stuff

4- "Whoever obeys his wife, Allah will throw them on their face into the fire. It was said: Whats meant by obedience? He replied: That you seek their view/opinion on bathing, weddings, feasting, mourning & fine clothing"

5- "Obeying the wife brings regret/remorse"

* So a Shi'ee would expect a woman to probably cook for a feast, but have no say. Help prepare a wedding, but have no say, sis can't even have an opinion on bathing or choose nice clothes *

Btw, if someone obeys Fātimah RA will they be filled with regret/remorse?

6- "Be wary of the opinions of women, for indeed within it there's weakness, feebleness & failure"

7- "In opposing The Women there is Barakah"

But Ali RA didn't oppose Fātimah Az Zahrā when she didnt want to pledge allegiance to Abū Bakr, did Ali RA not have Barakah? Also, this narration is from Ali RA??

8- "Every person whose woman runs/plans something, then he is cursed"

9- "Whenever The Prophet ﷺ intended for war, he would call his women seek their opinion & then oppose it"

This narration implies The Prophet looked down on his women and treats them in bad manner. Imagine someone calls you, then asks for your advice, then opposes. أعوذ بالله

Whats worse is, the hadith is generic, it doesn't specify a battle. This implies The Prophet would call his women everytime, just to oppose them?

10- "Seek refuge in Allah from the evil of your women, be wary of their choices & do not obey them in good for they call you towards evil. And The Messenger said: Women dont discuss opinions in private, & they dont obey their relatives. Indeed a woman when she grows old, the best

of the 2 parts (Good) goes and the worst of the two parts stay (Evil), that is she becomes barren, her character becomes bad & her tongue becomes sharp. Indeed when a man grows old, the worst of the 2 parts go, the best of the 2 remain. That is his intellect returns, his opinions

become strong, and he has good character"

*What twisted belief is this?*

O Shia women, is this your honor and status in your Deen?

Wallahi Ahlus Sunnah command us to honor you and treat you fairly. We are told the best of us is he whose best to his wife. We are told, Jannah

lies under your feet as a mother, as a daughter with a good upbringing, she secures her Fathers Jannah.

May Allah save us and keep us firm on our Deen

Aameen

@SunniDefense @Noor_as_Sunnah @EbnHussein1424 @bu_noor89 @MurrahSays @makh4n @MuftiFendi @h_sufia @BroHajji