Read on Twitter
I& #39;m making this thread as an "answer" to oomf& #39;s thread on how Eren being the father of Historia& #39;s child doesn& #39;t make any sense. But
https://abs.twimg.com/emoji/v2/... draggable="false" alt="‼" title="Doppeltes Ausrufezeichen" aria-label="Emoji: Doppeltes Ausrufezeichen"> Even though I believe he is the father, I get why people doubt it and I respect that. But seeing people call it nonsense is just getting annoying.
Eren being the father of Historia& #39;s child makes sense, chronologically, character-wise, and narrative-wise. The chronology in AoT rn is still not 100% clear. There are still elements we need to complete it. So it& #39;s not a valid point to debunk a theory, since it& #39;s a theory itself.
Mikasa being in love with Eren isn& #39;t an argument as to why he can& #39;t be the father. Furthermore, if you payed attention to Historia& #39;s character, she& #39;s not the type to care about wether or not she should make a kid with the one she supposedly loves, because of another& #39;s feelings.
Now, I& #39;ll use their relationship *post timeskip* as an argument aswell.
These pages prove that they both support eachother in some way:
Chapter 106 (p. 21, 24)
Chapter 107 (p. 12, 23, 25 - 27, 29)
Chapter 108 (p. 17)
Chapter 123 (p. 40, theory!)
Chapter 130 (p. 9, 10, 12 - 16).
These pages prove that they both support eachother in some way:
Chapter 106 (p. 21, 24)
Chapter 107 (p. 12, 23, 25 - 27, 29)
Chapter 108 (p. 17)
Chapter 123 (p. 40, theory!)
Chapter 130 (p. 9, 10, 12 - 16).
These pages don& #39;t have a lot of meaning if you don& #39;t have the context as to why they& #39;re such allies. For context you& #39;d have to read the uprising arc again, otherwise you wouldn& #39;t get what/how much they mean to eachother. Because that& #39;s where they started to understand eachother.
Also, know that Historia always gave Eren his motivation whenever he needed it the most. The child& #39;s safety is already something that pushes Eren to go through the hell he is in right now. But it being Eren& #39;s child would give it a lot more meaning and symbolism.
Historia is already aware of Eren& #39;s goal atp, she already knows WHY he& #39;s wanting commit global genocide. And she knows, that even though she would "happily" sacrifice herself, he wouldn& #39;t let her do it. Because Eren most likely knows she actually doesn& #39;t want to be sacrificed.
Historia is then remembered that she was the one who claimed that she would stay his ally, even if it meant being humanity& #39;s ennemy in chapter 66 (p. 27).
So, why do people still claim that Historia is disagreeing with/against Eren now that she stayed true to her statement?
So, why do people still claim that Historia is disagreeing with/against Eren now that she stayed true to her statement?
Nobody would ever 100% agree with genocide. But, the reasons behind the genocide can make some people actually agree with what will come out of it. In Historia& #39;s case: her, her child, her island, and all the future generations of Paradisians will forever be free.
So, that she agrees shouldn& #39;t be a surprise. Especially if you re-read the uprising arc, where she claimed that she wanted to let humanity be destroyed by titans because she was starting to hate it. (Chapter 66, p. 23)
Narrative-wise, you can& #39;t say that love and family isn& #39;t something important to the plot of AoT. Kruger& #39;s word are proof that someone you love, a family, a wife, even someone on the streets, is needed for the accomplishement of a mission.
That if you can& #39;t have any of these, the same errors will be repeated. The current Eren carrying his mission with one of his goals being to stop relatives of royal blood to eat eachother, starting with Historia, is actually a perfect example of that statement.
Good or bad isn& #39;t something present in AoT. Thinking Historia would disagree because Eren is commiting these horrors, is... debatable? But thinking she disagrees because she& #39;s a good girl that cares about everybody is simply a false statement. Read ch. 54 again.
She& #39;s the worst girl in the world, do you honestly think that she would do the same thing she refused to do 50 chapter ago, just because "killing is bad"? The baby daddy theory makes sense. You don& #39;t have to believe it, but stop trying to debunk it all the time. I rest my case.
This is the thread. All love, no hate just some thoughts and clarifications as a EH. https://twitter.com/abelenda98/status/1306032205458702343?s=19">https://twitter.com/abelenda9...
