This is a TERRIBLE, horrible, no good; very bad take. https://twitter.com/ascendedkee/status/1305549664696102912
Sigh....
And then the lambs always go too far. đŸ€ŠđŸŸâ€â™€ïž
https://twitter.com/legendarytingz/status/1305565854445326343?s=21 https://twitter.com/legendarytingz/status/1305565854445326343
Mariah is NOT the *reason* hip-hop / R&B collabs went mainstream, but she IS one of the best to do them.
Mimi has collabs with ODB, Da Brat, Missy, Jay, Nas, Mobb Deep, Bone, Busta, Mase & Puff, JD, Xscape, Joe, Snoop, Mystikal & P, Luda, Cam’ron, Jada, LL...
The reason (I’ve said this 80-billion times #OnHere) that Mariah has so many No. 1s was because she always had two versions of her singles: one for pop and one for urban. And the urban one might be a WHOLE OTHER SONG; same title.
And then Tommy used that same formula with JLo.
Also, Vision of Love may be pop, but if you think e’rybody Black didn’t have Mariah’s self-titled debut and that shit wasn’t all over Black radio, I’m here to correct the record.
Folks are gonna deliberately misunderstand this, but if you KNOW Whitney’s body of work is important to Black culture, you know Mariah’s is, too. The only difference pound for pound in them both balancing between pop and R&B is Mariah’s white-presenting.
https://twitter.com/lambuniversity/status/1305879260607913984?s=21 https://twitter.com/lambuniversity/status/1305879260607913984
”Embraced the culture” suggests she was an outsider. Ppl assumed that because of optics, but as soon as Mariah was secure enough to speak freely and be herself, we knew. Mariah ain’t stumble upon hip hop after she got signed.
https://twitter.com/thecalculation/status/1306056561517899779?s=21 https://twitter.com/thecalculation/status/1306056561517899779
So back to this goofy claim for a minute bc I see it too often.

Fantasy was Mariah’s first rap collab. And it a HELLUVA start, but that was 95. The golden era of R&B & rap collabs was WELL underway. Mary, Jodeci and SWV were already bodying it.
https://twitter.com/legendarytingz/status/1305879100339433472?s=21 https://twitter.com/legendarytingz/status/1305879100339433472
Janet & Mike had both done rap features already. Janet had done a couple. Yo, Arsenio and Fox had brought rappers into living more middle America living rooms, but it was still a couple of more years post-“Fantasy” before WHITE pop artists got into collabs in a real way.
And Mariah helped, sure, but I’d like to direct everyone’s attention to the fact that rap was starting to make itself at home on the dance and pop charts, period. (The Bad Boy HitMen say hello)
These are just some of the rap songs/artists who were cracking the Hot 100. It’s significantly more if we’re talking Top 20. Even “Slam” was No. 2 on the Hot 100. “Nuthin’ But a G Thang” was No. 2 on the Hot 100.
https://twitter.com/naima/status/1306074340077850624?s=21 https://twitter.com/naima/status/1306074340077850624
“Hip Hop Horay” was top 10 on the Hot 100 AND Billboard Dance chart. Prior to that, so was OPP, AND MTV changed the whole network theme song to an “OPP” remix.

Mariah didn’t single handedly bring hip-hop to the mainstream masses; please watch some MTV clips from the early ‘90s
Lambs, just because we don’t wanna give Mariah sole credit for bringing rap to mainstream doesn’t mean you have to make arguments for her contributions in my mentions. I’m clear - that’s where I started with this.
To close, this whole conversation is exactly why I never wanna see Mariah in a Verzuz, because #yall will make it annoying.
You can follow @naima.
Tip: mention @twtextapp on a Twitter thread with the keyword “unroll” to get a link to it.

Latest Threads Unrolled: