Read on Twitter
Ever since 2018, a theory became quite popular among the Attack On Titan fandom: Eren is Historia& #39;s baby dad. In this thread, I will elaborate why that isn& #39;t possible. This will be a long thread.
• First of all, it is literally chronologically impossible for Eren to be the father of Historia& #39;s baby. Floch said he met Eren 10 months ago (chapter 125, page 32), during the same time he ONCE met Historia (because chapter 130 is the only instance they appear alone).
Therefore, even IF after just one try Historia was impregnated, then the baby should have already been born. But that didn& #39;t happen, because it isn& #39;t Eren& #39;s baby hence Levi& #39;s line, "We just need to wait a few MONTHS for her to give birth" (chapter 112, page 37).
• Secondly, it goes against Historia& #39;s character to even suggest for Eren to be the father of her child. Although this fandom likes to put female characters against each other, Historia and Mikasa are friends.
Example of their friendship: (chapter 107, 16).
Example of their friendship: (chapter 107, 16).
You might say "Historia doesn& #39;t know about Mikasa& #39;s feelings for Eren" and that she was just "genuinely asking", instead of teasing. To that, I& #39;ll give you another example of another one of Mikasa& #39;s friends (Armin) teasing Mikasa about her crush on Eren (chapter 34, page 30).
In short: all of Mikasa& #39;s friends know about her feelings for Eren and they constantly tease her about it.
You could also say "So what?". Why would Historia care about the fact that she is asking her best friend& #39;s love interest, to have a child with her?
You could also say "So what?". Why would Historia care about the fact that she is asking her best friend& #39;s love interest, to have a child with her?
Because Historia cares about people. For years, the same people who believed Eren was Historia& #39;s baby dad, also thought that she supported the rumbling and was plotting everything behind the 104th& #39;s back. Unsurprisingly, they were all wrong (chapter 130, page 13).
To believe Historia asked Eren to have a child with him (despite her knowing that her best friend loves him) is the same thing as thinking Historia would agree with a plan that destroyed almost the entirety of humanity, it simply goes against the basics of her character.
• Even IF OOC Historia asked, Eren wouldn& #39;t accept it.
When Zeke asked Eren what he was going to respond about Mikasa& #39;s feelings, he didn& #39;t reject them. Instead, he answered: "What the hell are you talking about? I& #39;ve got four more years to live at most". (chapter 130, page 17)
When Zeke asked Eren what he was going to respond about Mikasa& #39;s feelings, he didn& #39;t reject them. Instead, he answered: "What the hell are you talking about? I& #39;ve got four more years to live at most". (chapter 130, page 17)
If Eren can& #39;t answer Mikasa about her feelings because he knows he is going to die (and that& #39;s what he literally said), then why would he have a child with someone else? A child that would soon be fatherless? What purpose does that benefit?
Not long before Eren& #39;s conversation with Zeke, he was breaking down in front of a child he just saved (chapter 131, pages 11,12) because he knew he was going to be responsible for the deaths of billions of people. It makes literally no sense for Eren to have a child with anyone.
• It would go against the narrative of the manga, if Historia were to have a child with Eren
The manga starts with Mikasa saying "Itterasshai" to Eren. That& #39;s the only numbered page (13) from the first chapter. But the story didn& #39;t just begin with them.
The manga starts with Mikasa saying "Itterasshai" to Eren. That& #39;s the only numbered page (13) from the first chapter. But the story didn& #39;t just begin with them.
In this last arc especially, Isayama has more than ever before put the spotlight in Eren and Mikasa& #39;s relationship.
Examples:
1- (chapter 102, page 13)
2- (chapter 108, page 26)
3- (chapter 112, page 25)
4- (chapter 121, page 6)
Examples:
1- (chapter 102, page 13)
2- (chapter 108, page 26)
3- (chapter 112, page 25)
4- (chapter 121, page 6)
More examples:
5- (chapter 123,page 23)
6- (chapter 126, page 27)
7- (chapter 130, page 16)
8- (chapter 132, page 9)
5- (chapter 123,page 23)
6- (chapter 126, page 27)
7- (chapter 130, page 16)
8- (chapter 132, page 9)
In conclusion, Isayama is building up their relationship more than he ever did with any other couple (Armin x Annie, Falco x Gabi or even Ymir x Historia). Why do you think he& #39;d do that, only to have Eren be the father of a child with someone else? It goes against the narrative.
We have also recently discovered that Eren was responsible for killing Historia& #39;s whole family, including the only person who loved her as a child, Frieda. (chapter 121, pages 25,26,27 and 28) Yet another reason why narrative wise, it doesn& #39;t make sense for him to be the father.
So, when I said there are PLENTY of reasons to disprove this "theory", I mean it. Historia having a child with Eren doesn& #39;t make sense, chronologically, character wise and narrative wise.
