reasons why I think the hc of amity being a scorpio is superior and accurate to any other amity astrology hc: a thread
1. because she literally is!!!!

2. because she could get doofenshmirtz absent parenting vibes saying something about being born in late November and not having a baby blanket / learning her first heat spell like that

3. bc scorpios commit HARD to crushes like instantly, this one needs no context whatsoever

4. bc scorpios get MAD when people are dishonest and tend to make a big/public thing of being lied to (Luz abomination thing)

5a. very... complicated friendships?? scorpios are loyal but not very upfront so that would fit with her trying to protect willow but not explaining it to her

5b. very... complicated friendships? scorpios tend to prefer friendships where they have more control/dislike vulnerability, hence the platonic reliance on abominations

6. halloween is a scorpio birthday and I feel like a halloween birthday would be VERY amity

7. a lot of us have trust issues, that's also quite her in terms of parental stuff

8. very blindly dedicated/ambitious - single track mind once there's a goal (the emperors coven) and can get quite upset/feel useless if that goal is thrown off or in conflict to new things

9. doesn't always hate it but definitely AWFUL at coping with change at least for a bit

10. NO sympathy for ex-friends or anyone who insults current friends/crushes, easily rude to those people despite other social anxiety (boscha)