Read on Twitter
Fun fact #2:
Colorado& #39;s COVID-19 Modeling Group estimates that if we stopped social distancing and stopped wearing masks, 13,370,000 Coloradans would become infected with Covid-19.
Which is weird, as Colorado only has 5,841,000 residents.
Read on.
1/10
Colorado& #39;s COVID-19 Modeling Group estimates that if we stopped social distancing and stopped wearing masks, 13,370,000 Coloradans would become infected with Covid-19.
Which is weird, as Colorado only has 5,841,000 residents.
Read on.
1/10
1st the model. The COVID-19 Modeling Group (CMG) made an app of their model. @GovofCO Polis said it& #39;s the same data used in CMG reports to him. Here is a screenshot of the model with social distancing & mask wearing set to 0.
It results in 5,513,600 Symptomatic Infections
2/10
It results in 5,513,600 Symptomatic Infections
2/10
The model is available at https://cucovid19.shinyapps.io/colorado/
3/10">https://cucovid19.shinyapps.io/colorado/...
3/10">https://cucovid19.shinyapps.io/colorado/...
BTW 5,513,600 Symptomatic Infections represents 94.4% of Colorado& #39;s 5,581,000 citizens. That& #39;s a Reproduction number of about 18.
The CDC estimates R at about 2.5.
But wait, there& #39;s more...
4/10
The CDC estimates R at about 2.5.
But wait, there& #39;s more...
4/10
The CMG model also calculates Asymptomatic Infections. Here is a portion of a table where the CMG shows the values for the fraction of infected individuals who are symptomatic. Notice the incredible precision with which these values are known!
5/10
5/10
Using the data from the chart & the population of each age category, the population-wide fraction of individuals who are symptomatic is about .412
That is, CMG believes 41.2% of infections in Colorado are symptomatic
The CDC estimates that 60% of cases are symptomatic
6/10
That is, CMG believes 41.2% of infections in Colorado are symptomatic
The CDC estimates that 60% of cases are symptomatic
6/10
If 5,513,600 symptomatic infections represent 41.2% of total infections, total infections = 13,371,000!!!
That is quite an accomplishment for a state of 5,841,000
And the point of all this:
7/10
That is quite an accomplishment for a state of 5,841,000
And the point of all this:
7/10
@GovofCO Polis bases a lot of his decisions on what the CMG tells him. But the CMG model is deeply flawed and produces insane results when SD and masks are set to 0.
And as I wrote in this article, insane models result in insane actions.
8/10 https://thefederalist.com/2020/08/13/insane-model-means-colorados-covid-19-policies-are-essentially-based-on-tarot-cards/">https://thefederalist.com/2020/08/1...
And as I wrote in this article, insane models result in insane actions.
8/10 https://thefederalist.com/2020/08/13/insane-model-means-colorados-covid-19-policies-are-essentially-based-on-tarot-cards/">https://thefederalist.com/2020/08/1...
Final word: Please tell me if you see something wrong with my analysis (I& #39;m looking at you CMG & @CDPHE). I have reviewed the code, parameters & docs, but it is Byzantine and I may have missed/misinterpreted something. I will correct any errors discovered.
Links follow
9/10
Links follow
9/10
Model equations (lots of errors):
https://github.com/agb85/covid-19/blob/master/Shiny%20App/www/covid19model.pdf
Model">https://github.com/agb85/cov... parameters (many seem unchanged since April)
https://github.com/agb85/covid-19/blob/master/Model/Model%20params.csv
Model">https://github.com/agb85/cov... documentation (mask numbers = wild guesses?):
https://github.com/agb85/covid-19/blob/master/Shiny%20App/www/SEIR%20Documentation_29290701.pdf
10/10">https://github.com/agb85/cov...
https://github.com/agb85/covid-19/blob/master/Shiny%20App/www/covid19model.pdf
Model">https://github.com/agb85/cov... parameters (many seem unchanged since April)
https://github.com/agb85/covid-19/blob/master/Model/Model%20params.csv
Model">https://github.com/agb85/cov... documentation (mask numbers = wild guesses?):
https://github.com/agb85/covid-19/blob/master/Shiny%20App/www/SEIR%20Documentation_29290701.pdf
10/10">https://github.com/agb85/cov...
