Read on Twitter
Supreme Court to setup 11-judge bench ; to relook Indira Sawhney and 50% cap on reservation which is now observed only in its flouting cc #core3 @cbcnn_Pilid https://www.republicworld.com/india-news/law-and-order/sc-hears-arguments-on-reservation-bench-told-to-refer-case-to-larger-b.html
Foundations like stare decisis & the law of predecents do not work in #IdeaOfIndia -- you can make it appear to work for a while.
It starts with the Tamilnadu exception.
* If you grant exception to X and do not bother to develop a justification for that exception.
* Then you have to grant that exception to everyone.
No workaround to these basic principles, particulary in social media age.
* If you grant exception to X and do not bother to develop a justification for that exception.
* Then you have to grant that exception to everyone.
No workaround to these basic principles, particulary in social media age.
If 95% of Tamilnadu can be oppressed --- then --
Why cant 85% of Maharashtra be oppressed too?
What is "oppressed" ? What are the quant checks and balances? https://www.republicworld.com/india-news/law-and-order/sc-hears-arguments-on-reservation-bench-told-to-refer-case-to-larger-b.html
Why cant 85% of Maharashtra be oppressed too?
What is "oppressed" ? What are the quant checks and balances? https://www.republicworld.com/india-news/law-and-order/sc-hears-arguments-on-reservation-bench-told-to-refer-case-to-larger-b.html
If there are no judiical principles and no doctrine of scrutiny -- then you should immediately FAIL SAFE and drop back to a more basic system of proportionate representation.
Immediately disaggregate castes and grant prop share in public jobs/edu. Action moves to private sector
Immediately disaggregate castes and grant prop share in public jobs/edu. Action moves to private sector
otherwise what happens in a very stable anti democratic faction system emerges - like Dravidianism. Which is factions who can form a majority will immediately close ranks and capture the system & state just by preventing its scrutiny. @prk1949
typos:
what happens is: "a very stable anti-democratic faction system emerges"
the stability is only threatened by outside attempts to scrutinize the regime. You can see this in Tamilnadus antics with the Janarthanam Commission @prk1949
what happens is: "a very stable anti-democratic faction system emerges"
the stability is only threatened by outside attempts to scrutinize the regime. You can see this in Tamilnadus antics with the Janarthanam Commission @prk1949
