The first hearing on the Fortnite/app store dispute is live right now. https://twitter.com/jbrowder1/status/1298007512050892800
This is a temporary restraining order hearing sought by Epic games, and it's starting off with their lawyers getting bench slapped for bringing case cites they didn't raise in their briefing or inform defense counsel about.
At the heart of the suit, Epic is arguing that Apple requiring developers to go through the app store to make in app purchases is an antitrust violation.

Epic also says it's suffering ongoing harm from Apple pulling the game from the app store, both finances and reputation.
"I get to interrupt, that's MY privilege" are not words you ever want to hear from your judge.
Epic is arguing that the harm to the consumers from not being able to access the game they already paid for is causing their company reputational damage - this is important in getting a TRO because they have to show harm that can’t be remedied by getting paid off in money alone.
Epic admits they buried their own payment system in a build they submitted to Apple for approval. They acknowledge this is in violation of the ToS, but that the terms shouldn’t be enforced because of it’s an illegal monopoly - the antitrust claim.
Judge says that Apple may have overreacted by removing other Unreal engine-based games without definitive correlation to Epic Games. Apple says there is a separate entity/account for the engine, but that it’s owned and maintained by Epic Games itself.
Apple says they terminated the related Unreal engine account because they feared Epic would simply re-release the payment engine via the other account.

Epic replies that they are two separate accounts regardless of being paid for by the same person/business.
Apple’s second chair lawyer tries to jump in on first chair’s argument and is told to sit back down by the judge. “I don’t believe Mr. Doren needs your help.”

Benchslap count: Epic 2, Apple 1.
Judge is trying to determine whether Epic is likely to succeed in the end at proving Apple is violating antitrust. She says it’s difficult to predict - the market has a high barrier to entry, but that Epic is suing Google for the exact same thing shows it’s not a monopoly.
Epic says Apple has prevented others from competing within its own App store, and that constitutes antitrust behavior despite the existence of other app stores in other ecosystems.
You can follow @loki_esq.
Tip: mention @twtextapp on a Twitter thread with the keyword “unroll” to get a link to it.

Latest Threads Unrolled: