Because it’s an always exciting, edgy, original idea. 30 times Superman has been evil/mind controlled/ otherwise marketed as “guess what?! now he’s scary!”

Justice Lords Superman

Red Kryptonite Smallville

Black Kryptonite, All Star

Twice in the Animated series

Hush

Superman the Dark Side

Twice Eclipsoed

Twice Jokerized

Once Cheetahed

3 times by Bryne not including the sex tape issue (look it up if you don’t know. I’m not talking about it)

Dc Comics Presents #17

Earth 2. Before you go “actually..” no I’m not counting other Bizarros, Ultraman, Prime, Black Zero, Cyborg Superman, Nazi Superman, Eradicator, so on so on. This was marketed so long as evil scary Superman I gotta count it

Speaking of elseworlds

3 fun retro examples

Darkseid War

Controlled by Maxwell Lord

Superman 3

Knightmare

Trigon possessed

Injustice of course

Superman/ Batman Absolute Power

Not by DC but counting because again the premise being blatantly “get this wild idea! What if he had a bit of an edge to em”

Anyway I’d play that Suicide Squad game. Looks fun. Looks like there’s lots of cool Superman stuff in it if not Superman’s character.