Read on Twitter
So this umari has been screaming and barking and saying that the mother of the believers means that we cannot curse, disassociate etc and it means they are pious. Firstly, I'd ask him to show us where he got this from? Any hafith to back this up? None at all. https://twitter.com/mhdazamali/status/1289329081104756736
He cannot show a thing to back up that the mother of the believers means they're all pious and ritcheous. Secondly, if we opppse someone who opposed the prophet, this is nothing wrong. However, I have got some daleel, just some, to show u the verse was revealed for Talha.
Dur Al manthur vol 6 article 643: " It was narrated by ibn Abi Hatim from Ibn marduya from Ibn Abbas that this verse was revealed for a man who was adamant on marrying one of the wives, who was Aisha.
It was narrated by ibn marduya from Ibn Abbas that he said that a man said:
It was narrated by ibn marduya from Ibn Abbas that he said that a man said:
"When Muhammad dies, I shall marry Aisha" thus this verse was revealed.
Ibn jalil and ibn Hatim narrated from abdurahman b Zayd ibn Aslam that "word reached the holy prophet that a man was saying that when the prophet dies, I shall marry so and so after him .
Ibn jalil and ibn Hatim narrated from abdurahman b Zayd ibn Aslam that "word reached the holy prophet that a man was saying that when the prophet dies, I shall marry so and so after him .
and that hurt the prophet. So the verse was revealed.
Ibn Abi Hatim narrated from Al suddi that he said:" Talha b ubaydullah said" Why is Muhammad forbidding our(female) cousins from us (meaning Aisha) and he Muhammad married our women?!"
Ibn Abi Hatim narrated from Al suddi that he said:" Talha b ubaydullah said" Why is Muhammad forbidding our(female) cousins from us (meaning Aisha) and he Muhammad married our women?!"
When he dies, I shall marry his wives after him. Thus the holy verse was revealed.
This clear cut alone shows it, and I've only shown this daleel as there are many. If u had studied a bit ud have known. Jaahil.
This clear cut alone shows it, and I've only shown this daleel as there are many. If u had studied a bit ud have known. Jaahil.
We also see it in Tafseer Ibn Katheer Volume 6 page 506 commentary of Surah Azhab, as well as many others. As I said, consensus jaahil. Go study. Nice try tho.
