Read on Twitter
My @NPR piece explores "K-pop" beyond idol music, which dominates Korea& #39;s musical representation in & outside the country. Also, why put "K-anything" in a musical genre? Key points from article in thread below: https://www.npr.org/2020/07/13/889759210/korean-pop-away-from-the-hit-factories">https://www.npr.org/2020/07/1...
1. K-pop is often synonymously used, in & outside Korea, as "a genre/style," 99.9% denoting "idol music." Think BTS, Black Pink, TWICE, GOT7, and 100s more. This is an understandable perception, since the English word "K-pop" came about w/ advent of idol system in late 90s.
2. But this also limits K-music, which has a hugely diverse/interesting soundscape, to music that& #39;s most profitable w/ highest capital investment/gains (=music from idol industry, in case that wasn& #39;t clear)
3. If we expand "K-pop" to music beyond idols, what would even be the musical boundaries? Would Leenalchi (AWESOME band ft. in article) be K-pop in the way Hyukoh or Se So Neon are? Would IU& #39;s first album be K-pop in the way Kkot Galpi is?
4. For me that& #39;s the larger issue w/ "K-pop" - as a word, it doesn& #39;t say much about the music, just that it& #39;s "made in Korea." It erases the specific music of each act and otherizes/regionalizes music from non-dominant, non-white cultures. (Btw Koreans do this too!)
5. I think the word "K-pop" reflects self-imposed otherization as much as outsiders otherizing Korean music. Just think about this: why is BTS always lumped w/ K-pop, whereas Beyonce, Taylor Swift, Justin Bieber, etc, are never called A-pop?
6. I& #39;m not so naive as to suggest we should get rid of using "K-pop", which is already too mainstream. It may also be useful in observing some common patterns in the idol industry. (But then, maybe just call it "Korea& #39;s idol music/industry"?)
7. TLDR: Word "K-pop" has lots of baggage. Idol music& #39;s not all there is. It& #39;s often inadequate at showing particular *music* (which is why misleading to say "K-pop=genre"), and reflects (un)conscious otherizing of other cultures. Also, look up Leenalchi. https://www.npr.org/2020/07/13/889759210/korean-pop-away-from-the-hit-factories">https://www.npr.org/2020/07/1...
