Is the $TSLA/China relationship at risk? First, context: China is immensely important to $TSLAQs growth narrative. Many expect Shanghai to outproduce Fremont, some predicting replacement. Without China, sales would've been less than 60k in Q2, a steep decrease Y/Y. Why at risk?
1)🇨🇳 production dropped 10% M/M in June, to a total of 10.3k. Annualized this is 75K less than M3 production capability as per Q2 earnings report. Given glut of SR inventory, # of price cuts, and departure of Robin Ren, its reasonable to think that things aren't going as planned.
2) China Model Y was originally expected to debut in 2021 but is now expected to be moved up as early as this fall. Why pull up cannibalization?
3) 2 mysterious production halts in Q2. Rumors point to supply and demand challenges. Less production = less employed= less happy CCP
4) In May, Tesla secured a $565 million dollar loan for use only in Shanghai. Rumors are that this was a drawer agreement with many stringent restrictions and guarantees. (see thread: https://twitter.com/StultusVox/status/1258967538131775488?s=19).
5) Elon has made a few, shall we say, tone deaf tweets regarding communism. See: https://twitter.com/StultusVox/status/1280204582602321923?s=19
6) As @passthebeano points out, Chinese propaganda outlets, which were full steam in support of Tesla in Jan-Feb, have been (relatively) quiet recently:
7) Tesla has stumbled out of the gates with consumers. See brand issues: https://twitter.com/StultusVox/status/1267959987562860545?s=19
8) China consumer protection courts recently convicted Tesla of fraud for selling a damaged vehicle and attempting to cover it up. https://twitter.com/StultusVox/status/1279236381965987841?s=19 There are dozens of additional cases in the system, including for when Tesla tried to bait and switch HW 3.0 with 2.5
10) $TSLAQ in China! A number of anti-tesla activist have organically emerged in China, many of who were early adaptors who grew disillusioned with the company or believe it is a fraud. Follow a few of them here:
https://m.weibo.cn/u/1652969205?uid
https://m.weibo.cn/u/5476536320 
Of course, things could be going great in China and I could be overly pessimistic. The market certainly disagrees with me. However, to my eyes, there are substantial risks with China that many $TSLA bulls and bears alike aren't pricing in.
You can follow @StultusVox.
Tip: mention @twtextapp on a Twitter thread with the keyword “unroll” to get a link to it.

Latest Threads Unrolled: