picrews rated by how accurately i could make shinoa hiiragi in them, a thread (disclaimer this is not judging the picrews merely their ability to accurately give me shinoa)

really cute and i can definitely tell it's shinoa, plus i could do the bow, but the hair is too bright. 8/10

i can do the little hair braidy thing but no bow also the hair is the wrong color and it just doesnt really look like her. hair danglies arent thick enough and bangs are inaccurate. 5/10

hair is the closest to the right color BUT there was no brown eyes option bizarrely. you'll notice at this point that i default to giving her a bun in a lot of these bc i cant get her actual hairstyle. there IS a bow but it's not the right size. hair danglies are.too short. 6/10

hair color is WAY off. inaccurate bangs. no bow. 4/10

first one with no hair up options. bows but not the one we need. bangs are inaccurate. the hair is the right color. very cute but it's not shinoa. 3/10

yeah that's shinoa!!!!! hair is a bit too light but has accurate bangs, danglies are fine, hair is accurate to canon and bow in the right place!!! 9/10

wrong bangs, haircolor is mostly accurate but a bit off, bow in the wrong place, no brown eyes, just doesn't look like her rly. 3/10

hair color is WAY off, no bow, doesn't look like her prob bc of the face shape. 3/10

color is terrible, hair down, bows in the wrong place. looks a lot more like mahiru than it does shinoa. 2/10

hair color is good but the rest of the hair besides the bangs is REAL OFF. bows are inaccurate. 3/10

accurate hair color. bow isnt in the right place but on top of the head is an improvement. bonus points for letting me give her a scythe. 7/10

hair length and color are all wrong, no bow, it literally does not look like her. 1/10 this barely even counts as shinoa

hair color is all wrong, danglies are the wrong length no hair up options, no bow, eyes are too light. but it DOES kinda look like her just by virtue of It Is Anime Picrew. 2/10

this is not shinoa. 1/10

hair color is good, hairstyle is inaccurate but resembles her canon hair vaguely and is very cute. no brown eyes. 5/10