Probably wont ever use eBay again. My worst nightmare came to realization. A SCAM thread. RT

I sold my last pair of 10.5 Court Purples last Sunday for $249.99. I shipped it out Tuesday and got it Thursday. He claims that I sent him a pair of loafers and a bag of rocks.
This is my worst nightmare. I purposely record myself packing packages every time I sell direct to consumer. Thank god I did because I have an entire video of me packaging the order. I also have the USPS drop off receipt which shows a 3 lb 2.4 oz package.
How can a bag of rocks and some loafers be only 3 lbs 2.4 oz? Weird. I even recorded myself weighing a pair of Air Jordan 1 Royal Toes in 10.5 and got 2 lb 12.8 lbs. This is without the USPS box. Anyways, I presented all this evidence to the buyer.
A couple minutes later, I get this response:

Who rips off tape during an ASMR unboxing video? Why isn't the video presented to me now if he already has it? This has happened to him often? Weird...

I decided it would be best not to respond. I thought he would back off.
FOUR hours later, to my surprise, I get another reply.

Ok. None of his relatives messed with the box. Got it.

Next, I check his "video"... Weird, the box is out of frame for 95% of the video.
He cuts open one side of the box and shows it in frame in the first 90 seconds of the video. Then he takes the box out of frame and "opens" it for about 5 minutes. At the end of the video, he pretends to take out the shoe box for the first time and acts surprised at the contents.
Some inconsistencies I found:

The tape on the side he opened has some air bubbles, but my video shows no air bubbles. Why didn't he take a peak inside the box when he had one side open? He took 5+ minutes to open the box and didn't look inside once?
Also, he just so happened to frame the side that wasn't completely destroyed from the tape. Weird. The end of the video shows him opening it from the opposite side of the framed side in the beginning of the video. Very specific framing to not show the box tears...
Anyways, now I am not sure what to do. I can send him the inconsistencies but I know he will open a case regardless. I'm worried about this because I have heard that eBay usually sides with the buyer. Maybe @purchasable can help? If you read this whole thread, I appreciate you.
You can follow @thxuAndy.
Tip: mention @twtextapp on a Twitter thread with the keyword “unroll” to get a link to it.

Latest Threads Unrolled: