Read on Twitter
Whilst Quran & Ahadith are above all other texts, it must be noted that there is no 'ijmaa' of scholars on the meaning of 'Khatm-e-Nabuwwat', 'La Nabi Abadi', death of Jesus (as) etc., although consensus is claimed.
Still, having great respect for these scholars, here is a list: https://twitter.com/Studentofmirza/status/1254489699810521094
Still, having great respect for these scholars, here is a list: https://twitter.com/Studentofmirza/status/1254489699810521094
'Khatam' not meaning total end:
- Hazrat Aisha (ra) (Durr e Manthūr, Vol. 5, p. 204)
- Ibn Khaldun (MuqaddamaĀ Vol. II, p. 54, Paris)
- Ali Bin Muhammad Sultan Al-Qari (Mullah Ali Qari) (Mauzooat Kabeer, p.69)
- Mohyuddin Ibn Arabi (Fosoosul Hikam, p. 140 / FutÅ«hÄt Makkiyyah)
- Hazrat Aisha (ra) (Durr e Manthūr, Vol. 5, p. 204)
- Ibn Khaldun (MuqaddamaĀ Vol. II, p. 54, Paris)
- Ali Bin Muhammad Sultan Al-Qari (Mullah Ali Qari) (Mauzooat Kabeer, p.69)
- Mohyuddin Ibn Arabi (Fosoosul Hikam, p. 140 / FutÅ«hÄt Makkiyyah)
- Syed Abdul Qadir Jelani (Al-Insanul Kamil, Ch. 36)
- Shah Waliullah Muhaddas of Delhi (Tafheemate Ilahiya, 53)
- Maulana Abdul Haye of Lukhnow (Dafi-ul-Wasawis fee asr ibn Abbas, p. 12)
- Shah Waliullah Muhaddas of Delhi (Tafheemate Ilahiya, 53)
- Maulana Abdul Haye of Lukhnow (Dafi-ul-Wasawis fee asr ibn Abbas, p. 12)
On 'La Nabi Abadi':
- Muhyuddin Ibn Arabi (Fotoohati MakkiyaĀ Vol. I, p. 569; Vol. II, pp. 3, 64, 417)
- Imam Muhammad Tahir Gujrati (Takmala Majmaul Bihar, p. 85)
- Imam Shaāarani (Al-Yawaqeet Wal Jawahir, Vol. II, p. 22)
- Nawab Siddique Hasan Khan (Iqtarabus Saāa, p. 162)
- Muhyuddin Ibn Arabi (Fotoohati MakkiyaĀ Vol. I, p. 569; Vol. II, pp. 3, 64, 417)
- Imam Muhammad Tahir Gujrati (Takmala Majmaul Bihar, p. 85)
- Imam Shaāarani (Al-Yawaqeet Wal Jawahir, Vol. II, p. 22)
- Nawab Siddique Hasan Khan (Iqtarabus Saāa, p. 162)
- Mullah Ali Qari (Al-IshÄāah Fi AshrÄtis-SÄāah, p. 226)
- Maulana Qasim Nanotwi (Taįø„zirun-NÄs, p. 28)
- Maulana Qasim Nanotwi (Taįø„zirun-NÄs, p. 28)
Death of Isa (as):
- Hazrat Imam Hassan (ra) (į¹¬abaqÄtul-KabÄ«r by Ibn Saād, Vol. 3)
- Hazrat Imam Malik (Majmaāul-BihÄr)
- Muhyuddin Ibn Arabi (TafsÄ«r Ibn āArabÄ«, p. 65)
These are some examples.
- Hazrat Imam Hassan (ra) (į¹¬abaqÄtul-KabÄ«r by Ibn Saād, Vol. 3)
- Hazrat Imam Malik (Majmaāul-BihÄr)
- Muhyuddin Ibn Arabi (TafsÄ«r Ibn āArabÄ«, p. 65)
These are some examples.
I reiterate: whilst these scholars are revered, I have only used their writings as supplements to how these concepts are explained in the Quran & Ahadith, and also to show that contrary to the claim, there isn't a consensus on these. If these scholars write something - ...
...in human error - contradicting the Quran & Ahadith, then their writings are considered as not credible. However, their views which are referenced in this thread do not oppose Quran & Ahadith, hence they are of value. I can confidently say that the writings of the...
...Promised Messiah - Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian (as) - are all in line with Quran & Ahadith. Alhamdulillah
He is the same Messiah & Mahdi whose advent was foretold in all major religions. His signs, prophecies and miracles anongst other things are witness to this fact
He is the same Messiah & Mahdi whose advent was foretold in all major religions. His signs, prophecies and miracles anongst other things are witness to this fact
