1/10 Let's take a close look at a dumpster fire of a BDC and how these BDCs use fake marks and leverage to boost fees - Franklin Square/EIG Power and Energy Fund. $3.5 Billion in asset value at 12/31/19 ($4.1 Billion cost). As I will show, leverage eliminates ANY equity value.
2/10 The asset value is broken down into $2.25B in equity and $1.24B in debt. The BDC charges a 1.75% management fee on TOTAL ASSETS which means that given the leverage the 1.75% turns into 2.7%. On $3.5B of asset valye, the extra 1% = $35 Million each year. Nice!
3/10 The portfolio is has $1.2B in 1L Loans, $565M in 2L Loans, $524M in 2L bonds, $323M in unsecured bonds, $722M in preferred and $214M in equity. 52% E&Ps, 30% Midstream, 12% Power, 6% service.
4/10 Given the upstream exposure, one would think there would be some pain in the portfolio, right? Well, check out below. Pref mark > 2L mark... easier to value private preferreds I guess.... Level 1 valuation is <1.5%, Level II is <30% and rest is Level III (wild wild west)
5/10 some of the marks are curious. Ascent resources equity was marked at 88c at YE19. Rosehill (which is prob in a tough spot with banks) was marked at 1.08x. A Canadian E&P company called Hammerhead was marked at 98c. Would love to work with these valuation experts for my comp
6/10 Checking in on the debt situation. total debt is $1.26B split amongst three tranches - 1st is a Goldman facility with $425M, 2nd is JPM with $311M, 3rd is $500M bonds. The BDC had a margin call and is in violation of covenants (ooops!). JPM reduced its facility by $126M.
7/10 So, with the debt guys looming. What IF the portfolio was marked to "fair value" and what would the result on the equity value be (recall, net equity value was $2.25B at YE19). Based on my recovery estimates, the portfolio should be marked at 32c on dollar
8/10 I individually valued each security in the portfolio using broker quotes where I could find them or applying my best guess depending on the situation (familiar with most of the portfolio). Below table lays out where i think things shake out.
9/10 So, with looming debt maturities and a rapidly declining portfolio value - what happens to the investors?
Well, luckily this BDC was sold to a bunch of private investors who don't have a market to sell the securities (they have to rely on tender offers by manager).
10/10 EIG has collected $250 Million in the last three years to deliver NEGATIVE annual returns. What a great business model. Heads I win, Tails you lose. Thanks for playing. fin.
Link to BDC if you want to look at the portfolio:
https://www.fsinvestments.com/investments/funds/fsep
You can follow @energy_wasted.
Tip: mention @twtextapp on a Twitter thread with the keyword “unroll” to get a link to it.

Latest Threads Unrolled: