Read on Twitter
We all want businesses reopened as soon as possible, but we have to follow doctors' orders for it to be safe to do so. That starts with better testing.
THREAD on testing - what Gov. Abbott has said, what the data shows, and what his and other experts recommend (1/28)
#txlege
THREAD on testing - what Gov. Abbott has said, what the data shows, and what his and other experts recommend (1/28)
#txlege
... @Senfronia4Texas, the TX House Chair of Public Health, made it clear:
"We have not even been able to scratch the surface of testing. We're all ready to get out of our houses and go back to work. But we don't even know what's out there"
https://www.expressnews.com/politics/texas/article/Gov-Abbott-again-restricts-press-access-for-15207829.php#
#txlege (2/28)
"We have not even been able to scratch the surface of testing. We're all ready to get out of our houses and go back to work. But we don't even know what's out there"
https://www.expressnews.com/politics/texas/article/Gov-Abbott-again-restricts-press-access-for-15207829.php#
#txlege (2/28)
...Texas regularly ranks between 48th and 50th in the country in per capita testing, and everyone on the front lines -- doctors, nurses, hospitals, local officials -- say we need more tests
Better testing is the top priority, so we are following it closely...
#txlege (3/28)
Better testing is the top priority, so we are following it closely...
#txlege (3/28)
...This THREAD examines:
1) What Gov. Abbot and his experts say about testing
2) The data we know and the data we lack
3) Are we following best practices, and what can we learn from outside TX?
First, what Gov. Abbott has said on testing the past few days...
#txlege (4/28)
1) What Gov. Abbot and his experts say about testing
2) The data we know and the data we lack
3) Are we following best practices, and what can we learn from outside TX?
First, what Gov. Abbott has said on testing the past few days...
#txlege (4/28)
...Since the @TexasHDC press briefing last week making it clear that testing must be the top priority, Gov. Abbott has had two press conferences to discuss testing
At each press conference, he failed to offer clear metrics or plans on the future of testing...
#txlege (5/28)
At each press conference, he failed to offer clear metrics or plans on the future of testing...
#txlege (5/28)
...Last Friday (4/17), Gov. Abbott, "insisted at the news conference that Texas was preparing to dramatically increase its testing capacity, but he did not provide details beyond suggesting a timeline of 'late April or early May.'"...
https://www.texastribune.org/2020/04/17/texas-reopening-greg-abbott-coronavirus/
#txlege (6/28)
https://www.texastribune.org/2020/04/17/texas-reopening-greg-abbott-coronavirus/
#txlege (6/28)
...and yesterday (4/21), Gov. Abbott “said the state’s testing capacity was increasing, though that is hard to track because the state has given little information on its overall testing capacity.”...
https://www.dallasnews.com/news/public-health/2020/04/21/as-texans-struggle-financially-gov-greg-abbott-pitches-500000-open-jobs-in-the-state/
#txlege (7/28)
https://www.dallasnews.com/news/public-health/2020/04/21/as-texans-struggle-financially-gov-greg-abbott-pitches-500000-open-jobs-in-the-state/
#txlege (7/28)
...The lack of info from Gov. Abbott is troubling. His experts have ideas, though.
Mark McClellan of @DukeMargolis, a well-respected expert, leads the TX health care task force. A recent paper by him and @ScottGottliebMD provides guidance for Texas on testing...
#txlege (8/28)
Mark McClellan of @DukeMargolis, a well-respected expert, leads the TX health care task force. A recent paper by him and @ScottGottliebMD provides guidance for Texas on testing...
#txlege (8/28)
...Better testing is the central tenet of the plan McClellan says is necessary "to mitigate the current COVID-19 pandemic wave and to limit and suppress future outbreaks"
https://healthpolicy.duke.edu/sites/default/files/atoms/files/covid-19_surveillance_roadmap_final.pdf
His paper lays out specifics for what Texas needs to do next...
#txlege (9/28)
https://healthpolicy.duke.edu/sites/default/files/atoms/files/covid-19_surveillance_roadmap_final.pdf
His paper lays out specifics for what Texas needs to do next...
#txlege (9/28)
...1. Rapid case detection: quickly test anyone high-risk or showing symptoms, set up data collection systems
2. Get local data efficiently, share all state info w/ national Syndromic Surveillance system to better track spread of COVID-19...
#txlege (10/28)
2. Get local data efficiently, share all state info w/ national Syndromic Surveillance system to better track spread of COVID-19...
#txlege (10/28)
...3. Test for exposure and immunity markers, which lets us learn who can’t get the virus and why
4. Get capacity to conduct rapid-response contract tracing, testing, and quarantine
Reminder those 4 steps are what Gov. Abbott’s top health adviser recommends...
#txlege (11/28)
4. Get capacity to conduct rapid-response contract tracing, testing, and quarantine
Reminder those 4 steps are what Gov. Abbott’s top health adviser recommends...
#txlege (11/28)
...Where is TX in those 4 steps?
We are likely still early in Step 2, with no clear metrics for testing now or in the future, and as we rank so low in per-capita testing
Which is why the 2nd big item we are following is the data we know and the data we lack...
#txlege (12/28)
We are likely still early in Step 2, with no clear metrics for testing now or in the future, and as we rank so low in per-capita testing
Which is why the 2nd big item we are following is the data we know and the data we lack...
#txlege (12/28)
...Per @TexasDSHS, as of 12pm today, Texas has conducted 205,399 tests to date. Of those tests, there are 20,196 cases reported.
https://txdshs.maps.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.html#/ed483ecd702b4298ab01e8b9cafc8b83 #txlege
That is a 9.83% positivity rate -- which is staggeringly high, and a clear sign of an epidemic...
#txlege (13/28)
https://txdshs.maps.arcgis.com/apps/opsdashboard/index.html#/ed483ecd702b4298ab01e8b9cafc8b83 #txlege
That is a 9.83% positivity rate -- which is staggeringly high, and a clear sign of an epidemic...
#txlege (13/28)
…Looking at the data, @ScottGottliebMD - one of McClellan's fellow experts - has demonstrated how high positivity rates in Texas and the U.S. demonstrate a high rate of infection and under-testing...
https://twitter.com/ScottGottliebMD/status/1252253958741135361
#txlege (14/28)
https://twitter.com/ScottGottliebMD/status/1252253958741135361
#txlege (14/28)
...For context, here's the data on positivity rates in tests *only* within high-risk populations of other diseases:
-Tuberculoisis, 1-2%
-Zika, 0.5-1%
-HIV, 0.4%
And positivity rates for COVID-19 in other countries:
-S. Korea, 2%
-Australia, 2%
-Germany, 7%
#txlege (15/28)
-Tuberculoisis, 1-2%
-Zika, 0.5-1%
-HIV, 0.4%
And positivity rates for COVID-19 in other countries:
-S. Korea, 2%
-Australia, 2%
-Germany, 7%
#txlege (15/28)
...Texas’ ~10% positivity rate is far above what we see in other diseases and in other countries with COVID-19, and is therefore nothing to celebrate
And remember - that's while we rank near last in per-capita testing...
#txlege (16/28)
And remember - that's while we rank near last in per-capita testing...
#txlege (16/28)
...Two other data points to highlight on testing:
1. 25% of those w/ COVID-19 show no symptoms, and therefore are unlikely to be tested
2. As many as 15% of the "quick test" Abbott ID tests come back with a false negative...
https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2020/04/21/838794281/study-raises-questions-about-false-negatives-from-quick-covid-19-test
#txlege (17/28)
1. 25% of those w/ COVID-19 show no symptoms, and therefore are unlikely to be tested
2. As many as 15% of the "quick test" Abbott ID tests come back with a false negative...
https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2020/04/21/838794281/study-raises-questions-about-false-negatives-from-quick-covid-19-test
#txlege (17/28)
...To summarize what the data shows:
Texas ranks near-last in per-capita testing; our ~10% positivity rate is still dangerously high; and some private testing coming on board now has more than a 1-in-8 chance of saying you don’t have COVID-19 when you do…
#txlege (18/28)
Texas ranks near-last in per-capita testing; our ~10% positivity rate is still dangerously high; and some private testing coming on board now has more than a 1-in-8 chance of saying you don’t have COVID-19 when you do…
#txlege (18/28)
...Finally, the @TexasHDC is closely tracking whether or not we are following the guidance of experts, and what other states are doing
The key question is: how many tests do we need, and how are we doing on the other steps Gov. Abbott's experts have laid out?...
#txlege (19/28)
The key question is: how many tests do we need, and how are we doing on the other steps Gov. Abbott's experts have laid out?...
#txlege (19/28)
...The question for how many tests we need can be looked at in two ways:
1. How many daily tests do we need to *start* to safely re-open the economy?
2. How many daily tests do we need to *fully* be safe to re-open the economy?
#txlege (20/28)
1. How many daily tests do we need to *start* to safely re-open the economy?
2. How many daily tests do we need to *fully* be safe to re-open the economy?
#txlege (20/28)
...On the first question, this piece from @keranews cites a study that just to *begin* re-opening the economy, Texas likely needs to do at least 44k tests/day
The most Texas has done in one day so far? 14,419...
https://twitter.com/keranews/status/1252601770234257411
#txlege (21/28)
The most Texas has done in one day so far? 14,419...
https://twitter.com/keranews/status/1252601770234257411
#txlege (21/28)
...On the second question, experts say we may need 5 to 20 million tests per day nationwide to fully re-open
That would be 450k to 1.8 million tests just for Texans alone
Again: the most Texas has done in a day so far is 14k...
https://abcnews.go.com/US/road-map-recovery-report-20-million-coronavirus-tests/story?id=70230097
#txlege (22/28)
That would be 450k to 1.8 million tests just for Texans alone
Again: the most Texas has done in a day so far is 14k...
https://abcnews.go.com/US/road-map-recovery-report-20-million-coronavirus-tests/story?id=70230097
#txlege (22/28)
...While we are orders of magnitude behind where experts say we need to be to safely re-open the economy, we are also behind on the next steps Gov. Abbott’s advisers have already laid out for states to follow…
#txlege (23/28)
#txlege (23/28)
...As a reminder, Gov. Abbott’s expert, McClellan, made clear recommendations that states must act on to contain the virus' spread, especially contact tracing
On updates w/ Members & staff, @TexasDSHS has provided no indication a tracing program is underway...
#txlege (24/28)
On updates w/ Members & staff, @TexasDSHS has provided no indication a tracing program is underway...
#txlege (24/28)
...A few counties are setting up their own testing & tracing programs, including Hays County:
https://www.fox7austin.com/news/hays-county-releases-procedure-for-covid-19-contact-tracing
The concern there is - like with stay-at-home orders - counties step up to lead, then the state comes in late and brings confusion...
#txlege (25/28)
https://www.fox7austin.com/news/hays-county-releases-procedure-for-covid-19-contact-tracing
The concern there is - like with stay-at-home orders - counties step up to lead, then the state comes in late and brings confusion...
#txlege (25/28)
...That we are so far behind on testing, and have nearly nothing to show on tracing, is only the start of concerns on Texas’ lack of a proper health response to COVID-19
We also need to expand coverage, secure more PPE supplies, and fix the nursing home crisis…
#txlege (26/28)
We also need to expand coverage, secure more PPE supplies, and fix the nursing home crisis…
#txlege (26/28)
...As @Senfronia4Texas and many others have said - we have done so few tests, we don’t even know what's out there
TX needs better testing, more transparency, and clear metrics - based on experts’ advice - on when we will have enough tests to get back to normal
#txlege (27/28)
TX needs better testing, more transparency, and clear metrics - based on experts’ advice - on when we will have enough tests to get back to normal
#txlege (27/28)
