its hard to think of a “Beyoncé vs. ____” in terms of solo catalog. hers is actually small when you get into the amount of albums everyone else has

most of her contemporaries have more albums than her, even the generation that came out right after.

you also can’t compare her hits vs anyone else’s. lmao everyone has their own criteria on what makes a hit a hit: single sold, billboard placement, radio play, gp recognition, longevity (ex: are they still playing this in the club/cookout etc.)

where she lacks one department, she makes up in other areas. example: Crazy in Love checks all the boxes whereas Love on Top has the longevity & gp recognition only. Irreplaceable, Single Ladies& Halo are in the same rank as Crazy in Love, but then you have RTW, Upgrade U etc.