We created a roster using the players by state database on pro football reference.

Texas gets the edge in QB, RB, OL, LB, S and P/K.

Georgia's advantage is at WR, TE, DL, and CB.

We'd expect a highly competitive game, but for Texas to edge it out at the end. https://twitter.com/Luke_Lynes/status/1250025966342152195

Texas Offense:
QB: Pat Mahomes, Drew BRees
RB: Adrian Peterson & Jamaal Charles
WR: Mike Evans, Dez Bryant, Emmanuel Sanders
TE: Vance McDonald
OL: Jason Peters, Marshall Newhouse, Travis Swanson, Marcus Cannon, Trent Williams.

Texas Defense:
DL: Miles Garrett, Michael Brockers, Jerry Hughes
LB: Von Miller, Brian Orakpo, Craig Robertson, Derrick Johnson
CB: Bradley Roby, Xavien Howard
S: Earl Thomas, Jamaal Adams

K: Justin Tucker
P: Shane Lechler

Georgia Offense:
QB: Deshaun Watson, Cam Newton
RB: Alvin Kamara, Nick Chubb
WR: Calvin Johnson, Demaryius Thomas, Tyreek Hill
TE: Evan Engram
OL: Cordy Glenn, Ben Grubbs, Max Garcia, Clint Boling, Michael Ola

Georgia Defense:
DL: Robert Mathis, Grady Jarrett, Cam Heyward
LB: Alec Ogletree, Thomas Davis, Daryl Smith, Justin Houston
CB: Rashean Mathis, Darius Slay
S: Antoine Bethea, Eric Berry

K: Will Lutz
P: Marquette King

As info - starters were selected by their best individual season, player groups were weighed against each other by overall talent during peak of career.