Read on Twitter
99 reasons why she left Islam and NONE of them are good.....so lets go trough this rubbish https://twitter.com/glass_union/status/1178769570938703879
Her first reason for leaving Islam is because baby girls buried alive will supposedly go to hell because of the following narration
"The woman who buries her baby girl alive and the maw’udah are both in Hellfire"
Source: Sunan Abī Dāwūd 4717 https://twitter.com/glass_union/status/1178769570938703879?s=20
"The woman who buries her baby girl alive and the maw’udah are both in Hellfire"
Source: Sunan Abī Dāwūd 4717 https://twitter.com/glass_union/status/1178769570938703879?s=20
This however is simply not true , many Ullema (scholars) have already addressed this narration
Shaykh Al-Albani for example writes:
"It does not mean the buried girl herself, but rather it only means the one for whom she was buried, whether it was the father, mother, .....
Shaykh Al-Albani for example writes:
"It does not mean the buried girl herself, but rather it only means the one for whom she was buried, whether it was the father, mother, .....
...or both together. If they shared in it and agreed upon burying their daughter, one will follow the second into Hellfire. As for the buried girl herself, there is no judgment upon her, neither Paradise or Hellfire"
Source: Mawsūʻat al-Albānī fī al-‘Aqīdah 5/918
Source: Mawsūʻat al-Albānī fī al-‘Aqīdah 5/918
Al-Mazhari writes:
As for the maw’udah mentioned in the tradition, what is intended is the one for whom she was buried, meaning the mother.
Source: al-Tafsīr al-Maẓharī 5/426
As for the maw’udah mentioned in the tradition, what is intended is the one for whom she was buried, meaning the mother.
Source: al-Tafsīr al-Maẓharī 5/426
Her second reason for leaving Islam is the incident in which ‘Uqbah said, “Who will look after my children?” to which the Prophet, blessings and peace be upon him, answered, “The Fire.” and then was executed. First lets find out who this "Uqbah" was... https://twitter.com/glass_union/status/1178769572717088768?s=20
...Uqbah bin Mu’ayt was one most vicious opponents of the Prophet (pbuh), and the Muslims. His vile acts of hatred towards the Prophet include; insults, mockery, throwing the entrails, blood, and waste of a camel on the Prophet as he prayed at the Kaba.....
..... Stepping on the Prophet’s neck while he was in prostration, spitting in the Prophet’s face, attempting to murder the Prophet by strangulation, rejoicing at the death of the Prophet’s son Abdullah, and more....
..so him being of the two captives to be executed after Badr should not come as a surprise given the suffrenign he had caused. Now lets address the prophet (pbuh) answering Uqbah by saying "the fire" , here we have two possibilities the first being that the prophet meant...
...that Uqbahs children are destined to hell hence the answer "the fire" this however does not make sense because his children (Umarah and Walid) became Muslims. The second possibility is that was using a specific style of speech called uslub al hakim ...
..so what he meant by is that ‘For you is the Fire,’ i.e. ‘Concern yourself with yourself and what is destined for you in the Fire, and leave the affairs of your children alone and this is the only possibility that makes sense and is thus the correct interpretation.
The third reason she cites is the narration in which the prophet stones a woman. Lets read the Hadith shall we?
https://twitter.com/glass_union/status/1178769572717088768?s=20
https://twitter.com/glass_union/status/1178769572717088768?s=20
so as we can see the woman CHOSE to come to Muhammad (pbuh) herself to get the punishment yet the Prophet turned her away until her child did not need to be weaned anymore! and then he entrusted the child to a Family so that the child would be taken care of...
... i guess the prophet's care and benevolence for the child was too much for this murtad (ex muslim) to handle thus causing her to apostatize?
Her fourth reason is because of a narration that supposedly claims that basta*d child is more evil than the parents this is anther lie, read the following.
https://twitter.com/glass_union/status/1178769572717088768?s=20
https://twitter.com/glass_union/status/1178769572717088768?s=20
So what is the background talked about in the comments?Here it is
ill be skipping her fifth point as the source she quotes is not in one of the main books of hadith so I dont have access to it so I cant verify the said narration but I would not be surprised if this was a weak/fabricated narration https://twitter.com/glass_union/status/1178769574155685888?s=20
In her sixth point she takes issue with this hadith because it denounces men acting effeminate and women acting masculine....uhhh how does this make Islam false? Also the hadith is talking about those emulate the other sex....
https://twitter.com/glass_union/status/1178769574155685888?s=20
https://twitter.com/glass_union/status/1178769574155685888?s=20
...its not cursing men born with a high pitched voice or women that are masculine looking etc.
Here she takes issue with the hadd punishment being applied on homosexuals who had intercourse again how does this make Islam false? so because u dont like a said ruling / punishment Islam is wrong? ….. nice nice https://twitter.com/glass_union/status/1178769575514689538?s=20
Furthermore its clear why Islam doesn't allow such behavior to be normalized , its detrimental to a healthy society. For example Children raised by non-heterosexual parents are more likely to be sexually abused by their parents, get an STD, do various drugs, commit crime, get ...
….depression, commit suicide, and end up non-heterosexual.
reasons 8-19 is just her foaming at the mouth about slavery if anybody is genuinely interested in learning about what slavery in Islam entails refer to the following https://yaqeeninstitute.org/jonathan-brown/slavery-in-islam-lecture/
She also asserts that the Sahabeah and the prophet (pbuh) "r*ped" slaves you can check the hadiths she cites in regards to that yourselves ...NONE of those said hadiths assert that nor do they imply it she is LYING
