Last week, I had a spontaneous chat with a C-suite exec at one of the major ad verification companies blocking ad $$ to the news industry:
Here are a few highlights from the conversation
:
Here are a few highlights from the conversation

I asked (paraphrased): âLayoffs are happening NOW. What are you doing to get ad $$ to local newsrooms?â
The exec replied: âWe have been educating brands for months now, but itâs hard to force brands to spend on the news when they believe it will harm them.â
The exec replied: âWe have been educating brands for months now, but itâs hard to force brands to spend on the news when they believe it will harm them.â
Me: âWant to bring me in to talk to them? Happy to.â (Shoot your shot, ladies.)
Exec: âNo thanks! Theyâre not blocking news sites anyway. Just COVID-related keywords. Weâre trying to convince them itâs ok to serve ads on then news. Just not the bad news.â
Exec: âNo thanks! Theyâre not blocking news sites anyway. Just COVID-related keywords. Weâre trying to convince them itâs ok to serve ads on then news. Just not the bad news.â

Exec (contâd): Keyword blacklisting is bad, arcane technology. We are moving them to âtrue contextual understanding.â Itâs simple and gets their spend back on instantly.â
Me: âOK. How does your technology work? Walk me thru how you classify content.â
Me: âOK. How does your technology work? Walk me thru how you classify content.â
Me:
Me: Heavily about death vs. moderately about death vs. a little bit about death. WHO CARES, itâs THE NEWS.
Exec (straight faced, probably): Brands care.
Exec (straight faced, probably): Brands care.
Me: Ok. Can you give me an example of a brand that has suffered losses - either in terms of brand equity or revenue - as a result of an ad placement on bad/sad news?
Exec: YES, LOTS! One sec, lemme pull some up for you.
Exec: YES, LOTS! One sec, lemme pull some up for you.
Exec [comes up empty-handed]: âWell, you know...what if you were a travel brand and your ad appeared next to an article about a plane crash?â
Me: Yes, but show me an example of that happening.
Me: Yes, but show me an example of that happening.
Exec: âOK, ha! Got one.â
Sends me this link to a study of how people reacted to brands that advertised on the video of a school shooting. (Not a *news article* covering a school shooting.)
I point out itâs a flawed study that proves nothing. https://marketingland.com/study-confirms-brands-worst-fears-about-unsafe-content-250650
Sends me this link to a study of how people reacted to brands that advertised on the video of a school shooting. (Not a *news article* covering a school shooting.)
I point out itâs a flawed study that proves nothing. https://marketingland.com/study-confirms-brands-worst-fears-about-unsafe-content-250650
Then it just devolves. Exec accuses me of calling âfake newsâ on a research study.
Then subtly tries turning the tables on me: âThere would certainly be no conversions on a school shooting article!â
Probably not. But what does that have to do with *brand safety*?
Then subtly tries turning the tables on me: âThere would certainly be no conversions on a school shooting article!â
Probably not. But what does that have to do with *brand safety*?
Exec [continues to go off track and even gets bizarrely personal]: âYou obviously have no empathy for marketers who are concerned about their brands. This is what they believe!â
Me:
Me:
Curious who I was talking to? It doesnât matter.
All the major ad tech players involved in the news blacklisting scandal are moving in lockstep to sell more deluded brand safety tech that simultaneously does NOT solve the news crisis.
They all sound like this:
All the major ad tech players involved in the news blacklisting scandal are moving in lockstep to sell more deluded brand safety tech that simultaneously does NOT solve the news crisis.
They all sound like this:

To re-iterate, the best place to be advertising right now is the news. The good, the sad, the bad. All of it.
The only people who think âsentiment analysisâ matters are the ones who are selling it for big $$$.
Learn more: https://branded.substack.com/p/good-news-you-can-advertise-on-bad
The only people who think âsentiment analysisâ matters are the ones who are selling it for big $$$.
Learn more: https://branded.substack.com/p/good-news-you-can-advertise-on-bad