i am challenging myself to listen to all of 1D’s discography because i want to know what drew people in

might make this a thread

UP ALL NIGHT:

ok but stole my heart >

i have no idea where ive listened to this song before but it’s one of the only songs that i recognise? it’s very 2011 but it’s a cute song

overall review: it’s not bad for a debut. it was definitely made for its time. some of the songs dragged on a little but it’s whatever. idk but stole my heart should’ve been a single

ok onto Take Me Home...

song the first song ‘live while we’re young’, lmao i only remember the chorus

not bad, it’s a fun song

the blonde highlight in zayn’s hair made his hair look more like icecream

mv is fun, i like the colour palette

kiss you

this is such a 2012-13 sound, it’s cute. definitely nostalgic. i spotted the jailhouse rock reference. not bad.

ok i don’t want to do song by song review, that’s too much work

see you by the end of the album

this just makes me think, wow they were lucky to be on radio everywhere

just a heads up (not like anyone cares but), i’ll finish this album tonight and listen to the rest tomorrow

‘I would’ is actually not bad

yeah definitely liking the general style of this album more than up all night

ok so i finished the album but got distracted by my moots so i lowkey don’t remember too much. lmao i’m so bad at this

final thoughts / overall review: i like the generally style of the album better than up all night, but i there aren’t as many memorable songs in this album

so the album’s alright

i hope it’s not harsh, i don’t dislike it in anyway but i don’t get the complete appeal yet

MIDNIGHT MEMORIES

ok, so i have listened to best song ever and story of my life. i like the direction this album is going, it’s a refresher from the first two albums. i’m ngl the SoML MV got me kinda emotional, it was nice

ok i’ll update my thoughts later on

alright, so i finished th album. i actually enjoyed listening to little white lies and better than words - it was a nice way to end the album.

generally, i liked this album. it was definitely a step-up from their previous 2, seeing as they were experimenting with other styles

just a note: don’t take my thread as an extensive review, i’m not taking this so seriously. so please don’t use this thread to form your own opinions. i’m just sharing a little bit of my experience, all in good fun

FOUR

ok i’m onto ‘where do broken hearts go’

i’ll update at the end