Read on Twitter
[1/n] This is a thread on my beloved Ramchandra Guha, who is not a Bengali but a Tamilan Da! He wears many hats: Economist, Environmentalist, Historian. We will look at the selected works of the man himself in the coming series of mega threads. @Ram_Guha
[2/n] There probably exists no other poet in the history of India other than Galib. न भूतो न भविष्यति, Na Bhuto Na Bhavishyati. As per Delhi University and JNU social sciences faculties. See the excerpts from the Book Indian- Unnatural Nation
![[2/n] There probably exists no other poet in the history of India other than Galib. न भूतो न भविष्यति, Na Bhuto Na Bhavishyati. As per Delhi University and JNU social sciences faculties. See the excerpts from the Book Indian- Unnatural Nation](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EVJsuctUcAAyCNR.png "[2/n] There probably exists no other poet in the history of India other than Galib. न भूतो न भविष्यति, Na Bhuto Na Bhavishyati. As per Delhi University and JNU social sciences faculties. See the excerpts from the Book Indian- Unnatural Nation")
[3/n] Well, the Maratha Empire took over most of the Mughal territories and it was not chieftains fighting for territory. It took 3 Anglo-Maratha wars for brits to take over. That’s an inconvenient fact for these faculties.
[4/n] Excerpts from the Book by Wg. Cdr(Ret). Dr. M.S. Naravane [ Father of the 28th COAS Manoj.M. Naravane]. I believe Armed forces men who graduated from the NDA over a generic academician who doesnt know which role he actually fills in[Guhaji filled several positions].
![[4/n] Excerpts from the Book by Wg. Cdr(Ret). Dr. M.S. Naravane [ Father of the 28th COAS Manoj.M. Naravane]. I believe Armed forces men who graduated from the NDA over a generic academician who doesnt know which role he actually fills in[Guhaji filled several positions].](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EVJs6tVVAAA82sE.png "[4/n] Excerpts from the Book by Wg. Cdr(Ret). Dr. M.S. Naravane [ Father of the 28th COAS Manoj.M. Naravane]. I believe Armed forces men who graduated from the NDA over a generic academician who doesnt know which role he actually fills in[Guhaji filled several positions].")
[5/n] For those who don’t know academia, an academician who claims to be jack of many unrelated trades is negatively perceived. Ask anyone who is working in Sensors- Chemical, material science, MEMS and electronics. Deans dont want to hire folks with such varied specializations
[6/n] Guha baba seems to be Economist, Environmentalist, Historian. See screenshots. Yet he excluded his affiliations with Institute of Economic growth, Delhi. What are you GUHA?
![[6/n] Guha baba seems to be Economist, Environmentalist, Historian. See screenshots. Yet he excluded his affiliations with Institute of Economic growth, Delhi. What are you GUHA?](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EVJtGWTU0AAHto4.png "[6/n] Guha baba seems to be Economist, Environmentalist, Historian. See screenshots. Yet he excluded his affiliations with Institute of Economic growth, Delhi. What are you GUHA?")
[7/n] 28 March 1737 Marathas had sacked Delhi from the Mughals.
![[7/n] 28 March 1737 Marathas had sacked Delhi from the Mughals.](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EVJtNKPUEAAnx03.png "[7/n] 28 March 1737 Marathas had sacked Delhi from the Mughals.")
[8/n] Interesting, Comrade Guha! This is ur sense of history? Did you ask your poor PhD or MS student to write these manuscripts for you? Did they do proper literature survey? That’s the only thing one needs to do in History related books. u dont have to put a solution forwards
![[8/n] Interesting, Comrade Guha! This is ur sense of history? Did you ask your poor PhD or MS student to write these manuscripts for you? Did they do proper literature survey? That’s the only thing one needs to do in History related books. u dont have to put a solution forwards](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EVJtXUOUwAAb6BQ.png "[8/n] Interesting, Comrade Guha! This is ur sense of history? Did you ask your poor PhD or MS student to write these manuscripts for you? Did they do proper literature survey? That’s the only thing one needs to do in History related books. u dont have to put a solution forwards")
[9/n] Comrade said on Golwalkar, what Golwalkar actually wrote and what Law commission said.
![[9/n] Comrade said on Golwalkar, what Golwalkar actually wrote and what Law commission said.](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EVJtg7vVAAA3Ha7.png "[9/n] Comrade said on Golwalkar, what Golwalkar actually wrote and what Law commission said.")
[10/n]ComradeGuha is a defender of Freespeech, anti-Sedition. Accusses Golwalkar of hate! Surprise! Premise-1
![[10/n]ComradeGuha is a defender of Freespeech, anti-Sedition. Accusses Golwalkar of hate! Surprise! Premise-1](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EVJton_UwAAfi3x.png "[10/n]ComradeGuha is a defender of Freespeech, anti-Sedition. Accusses Golwalkar of hate! Surprise! Premise-1")
[11/n]ComradeGuha is a defender of Freespeech, anti-Sedition. Nehruvian Surprise! Premise-2
History repeats they said!
![[11/n]ComradeGuha is a defender of Freespeech, anti-Sedition. Nehruvian Surprise! Premise-2History repeats they said!](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EVJtxEeU4AAMdyU.png "[11/n]ComradeGuha is a defender of Freespeech, anti-Sedition. Nehruvian Surprise! Premise-2History repeats they said!")
History repeats they said!
[12/n] The Nehruvian Dilemma and Ultimate insert! Comrade Guha skips it. But Golwalkar who never ruled a nation or a state is dangerous!
![[12/n] The Nehruvian Dilemma and Ultimate insert! Comrade Guha skips it. But Golwalkar who never ruled a nation or a state is dangerous!](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EVJuH77VAAIQ5q7.png "[12/n] The Nehruvian Dilemma and Ultimate insert! Comrade Guha skips it. But Golwalkar who never ruled a nation or a state is dangerous!")
[13/n] Freespeech, has a “however”. Yet was put to democratic public discussion by the law commission in 2018. Modi is diluting judiciary and democracy!
![[13/n] Freespeech, has a “however”. Yet was put to democratic public discussion by the law commission in 2018. Modi is diluting judiciary and democracy!](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EVJuQ4DU0AECwLu.png "[13/n] Freespeech, has a “however”. Yet was put to democratic public discussion by the law commission in 2018. Modi is diluting judiciary and democracy!")
[14/n] Mazdoor Union Zindabad; Down with Capitalism. Golwalkar opined on the shorcomings of democracy. Which is eerily similar to every Comrade’s rant!
![[14/n] Mazdoor Union Zindabad; Down with Capitalism. Golwalkar opined on the shorcomings of democracy. Which is eerily similar to every Comrade’s rant!](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EVJuakwUwAEWca2.png "[14/n] Mazdoor Union Zindabad; Down with Capitalism. Golwalkar opined on the shorcomings of democracy. Which is eerily similar to every Comrade’s rant!")
[15/n] Golwalkar’s thoughts on Muslims and how Comrade Guha has ignored it. I suggest you to read the book here. https://www.thehinducentre.com/multimedia/archive/02486/Bunch_of_Thoughts_2486072a.pdf
![[15/n] Golwalkar’s thoughts on Muslims and how Comrade Guha has ignored it. I suggest you to read the book here. https://www.thehinducentre.com/multimedia/archive/02486/Bunch_of_Thoughts_2486072a.pdf](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EVJukmrUEAAnY_5.png "[15/n] Golwalkar’s thoughts on Muslims and how Comrade Guha has ignored it. I suggest you to read the book here. https://www.thehinducentre.com/multimedia/archive/02486/Bunch_of_Thoughts_2486072a.pdf")
[16/n] I wonder why even comrade Guha excluded this about Muslims and Minorities from Golwalkar’s book.
![[16/n] I wonder why even comrade Guha excluded this about Muslims and Minorities from Golwalkar’s book.](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EVJur18UYAAWRXy.png "[16/n] I wonder why even comrade Guha excluded this about Muslims and Minorities from Golwalkar’s book.")
[17/n] Guha, Next series will cover spectrum of your articles on Ecology and how relevant they are. Reading your books and articles on Social issues; and comparing them with alternative points of view, I feel duped by your left liberal narrative.
