Ranking every winner of America’s next top model: a thread

24. Whitney (cycle 10)

Whitney just sucks. Most of her photos ranged from mediocre to just terrible. Even her best pics didn’t stand out and there is not pic in her portfolio I love. She was in the bottom 2 four times and we all know she only won for being plus sized

23. Keith (Cycle 21)

It’s pretty obvious Keith only won cause they wanted a male winner and he was the best looking male on the cast. Most of his photos just seem like he didn’t even try and he constantly had the same expression and even his few great photos were just a fluke

22. Nicole (Cycle 5)

Cycle 5 had a pretty weak cast of models but Nicole still didn’t deserve to win. She started off mostly mediocre and while I think she did get better as the cycle went on I still don’t think she ever delivered anything mind blowing

21. Lisa (cycle 17)

Imo Lisa was way more deserving of the win in Cycle 5 than in All Stars. Problem was she was extremely hit or miss. She would either give a great performance or produce awful messy joke shots. Her inconsistency is why she’s placed low

20. Saleisha (Cycle 9)

By no means did Saleisha deserve to win but I think her portfolio gets way too much hate. Her only terrible shot was the plant one but she did often take middle of the road pictures but I think she started to dominate once they went overseas

19. Sophie (Cycle 18)

Quite possibly the most overrated ANTM winner. Sophie did have two amazing shots in her portfolio but besides that she mostly coasted the whole singer and consistently took ok pictures and i feel she only won cause they wanted a Briti winner and alisha quit

18. McKey (Cycle 11)

This one hurts cause I do think McKey deserved to win. She consistently took good photos and she never delivered anything bad I just felt like while her photos were good she never took an amazing photo

17. Laura (Cycle 19)

I do think Laura starting the competiton off really well and was one of the early front runners for sure but the second half of the competition her photos took a steep decline and she was in the bottom 3 times

16. Yoanna (Cycle 2)

While I do not think Yoanna deserved to win she was still a good model. She started off good but nothing special but as the cycle went on especially the end game she delivered some beautiful photos like her memorable Helmet shot

15. Kyla (Cycle 24)

Probably unpopular opinion but I think Kyla was a deserving winner. She started off week but then became one of the most dominating models in the cast although I do think the judges slightly over praised her towards the end