1/ A small rant about Chinese works in the Chinese mantic arts Recently, I compiled a small thread of Indian astrological and astronomical works. With a bit of searching there I easily found around 20 of them that have been translated into English.
2/ Many of them are primary sources. Some primary sources have been translated multiple times.
This made me think about translations for similar works in the Chinese astrological tradition-or rather the lack of them. Off the top of my head I only know of about 6 of them.
3/
1.Lord Dong’s date selection 董公擇日, By Joey Yap
2.“Earth Study Discern truth” = 地理辨正Dili Bianzheng, also by Joey Yap
3 The Imperial Guide to Feng Shui & Chinese Astrology, by Aylward; a partial translation of the Xie Ji Bian fangshu 協記辦方書
4/ 4.Five Classics of Fengshui, by Michael Paton
5. The Di Tian Sui (滴天髓, a work on Bazi.
6. The Qiongtong Baolan 窮通寶鑑, also on Bazi.
5/ No. 5 and 6 were pub'd in Singapore in the 1990s; they are probably out of print. If I remember correctly 6 was transl. as "Inexhaustible treasure"

If you can add any more books to this list I will be most grateful.
7/ Western works speak of these as if they were the primary form of electional astrology for the Chinese. However, when you look at the Chinese sources, this *Hardly factors at all*. It is at most some calendarical curiosity.
8. Even the simplest and crudest forms of electional astrology are more concerned with looking at the actual *day* the wedding is conducted than the year. More advanced forms of electional see how the day reacts with the “horoscopes” of the bride and groom.
10/ In turn, some of the simplest forms of Chinese electional astrology—the 12-day cycle called in Chinese 建除 is utterly unknown in the English literature, with the exception of a few books published in the 1970s by (I think) Martin Palmer...
11/ and some academic books published about almanacs unearthed from Han-dynasty tombs.
12/ I once read that the western world’s knowledge of Taoism is about a century behind its knowledge of buddhism. I would think the same can be said about the Chinese mantic arts. We have barely scraped the surface of this immense tradition...
You can follow @edwardW2.
Tip: mention @twtextapp on a Twitter thread with the keyword “unroll” to get a link to it.

Latest Threads Unrolled: